Environmental News for a Healthier Planet and Life

U.S. Subway Platforms Have Highly Polluted Air

Health + Wellness
U.S. Subway Platforms Have Highly Polluted Air
A platform at the Christopher Street PATH station had the worst air pollution ever measured at a subway station. Billie Grace Ward / CC BY 2.0

It turns out, the subway is even dirtier than you imagined, at least in the four U.S. cities that make up the majority of the country's underground transport system.

A research team led by the NYU Grossman School of Medicine measured the air quality of 71 subway stations in New York City, Washington, DC, Philadelphia and Boston during the morning and evening rush hour. In every city, the concentration of airborne particles was at least twice as high within some stations when compared to the air outside.

"Our findings add to evidence that subways expose millions of commuters and transit employees to air pollutants at levels known to pose serious health risks over time," study lead author David Luglio, a doctoral student at NYU Grossman School of Medicine, said in a statement.

Of the four, the New York City subway system was the most polluted. At the Christopher Street station, one platform on the PATH line connecting New York and New Jersey had toxic air pollution at levels 77 times the air outside. The platform air was as polluted as the air surrounding a wildfire or building demolition.

"It was the worst pollution ever measured in a subway station, higher than some of the worst days in Beijing or Delhi," study coauthor and NYU Langone Department of Environmental Medicine professor Terry Gordon told The Guardian. "It just wasn't believable. My colleague went down there and his airways were feeling tight after an hour or so."

The other most polluted stations included Broadway in Boston, Second Avenue in New York City and 30th Street in Philadelphia.

Overall, the New York City subway system. was the most polluted and the Philadelphia subway system was the least. The national safe limit for particulate matter (PM2.5) air pollution is 35 micrograms per cubic meter. The average PM2.5 level for the subway systems recorded by the scientists was as follows, according to NYU:

  • PATH New York-New Jersey: 392 micrograms per cubic meter
  • MTA New York: 251 micrograms per cubic meter
  • Washington, DC: 145 micrograms per cubic meter
  • Boston: 140 micrograms per cubic meter
  • Philadelphia: 39 micrograms per cubic meter

In 2019, 5.5 million people rode the New York subway, while the PATH has a daily ridership of more than 284,000.

"As riders of one of the busiest, and apparently dirtiest, metro systems in the country, New Yorkers in particular should be concerned about the toxins they are inhaling as they wait for trains to arrive," Gordon told NYU.

The particulate matter was found mostly to consist of iron and organic carbon, which is released by the breakdown of fossil fuels or plant and animal matter. While iron is mostly not toxic, exposure to some types of organic carbon has been associated with greater risk of asthma, lung cancer and heart disease.

The study authors said more research needed to be done to determine the source of the pollution, why certain stations were so polluted and to what extent commuters and transit employees were at risk.

Gretchen Goldman, research director at the Union of Concerned Scientists, who was not involved in the study, told The Guardian that it also had important implications for environmental justice. Air pollution tends to disproportionately harm low income communities and communities of color

"As the scientific community works to better understand exposure and potential health effects of air pollution in the urban environment, I hope local decision makers use this valuable work to inform the best ways to address the known racial and socioeconomic inequities in air pollution exposure in US cities," Goldman said.

The measurements were all taken before the coronavirus pandemic hit, according to NYU.

Valley of the Gods in the heart of Bears Ears National Monument. Mint Images / Getty Images

By Sharon Buccino

This week, Secretary Haaland chose a visit to Bears Ears National Monument as her first trip as Interior Secretary. She is spending three days in Bluff, Utah, a small town just outside the monument, listening to representatives of the five tribes who first proposed its designation to President Obama in 2015. This is the same town where former Secretary Sally Jewell spent several hours at a public hearing in July 2016 before recommending the monument's designation to President Obama.

Read More Show Less
EcoWatch Daily Newsletter

By Anthony Richardson, Chhaya Chaudhary, David Schoeman, and Mark John Costello

The tropical water at the equator is renowned for having the richest diversity of marine life on Earth, with vibrant coral reefs and large aggregations of tunas, sea turtles, manta rays and whale sharks. The number of marine species naturally tapers off as you head towards the poles.

Read More Show Less
"Secrets of the Whales" is a new series that will start streaming on Disney+ on Earth Day. Disney+

In celebration of Earth Day, a star-studded cast is giving fans a rare glimpse into the secret lives of some of the planet's most majestic animals: whales. In "Secrets of the Whales," a four-part documentary series by renowned National Geographic Photographer and Explorer Brian Skerry and Executive Producer James Cameron, viewers plunge deep into the lives and worlds of five different whale species.

Read More Show Less
Spring is an excellent time to begin bird watching in earnest. Eugenio Marongiu / Cultura / Getty Images

The coronavirus has isolated many of us in our homes this year. We've been forced to slow down a little, maybe looking out our windows, becoming more in tune with the rhythms of our yards. Perhaps we've begun to notice more, like the birds hopping around in the bushes out back, wondering (maybe for the first time) what they are.

Read More Show Less
The brown pelican is seen on Queen Bess Island in Louisiana in March 2021. Casey Wright / LDWF biologist

Who says you can't go home again?

Read More Show Less