4 Best Gutter Guards for Heavy Rain [2022 Guide]

In this guide to the ideal gutter guards for above-average rainfall, you’ll learn:

  • What are the best gutter guards for heavy rain?
  • What factors should you consider when buying heavy rain gutter guards?
  • How do you choose the right gutter guard for your home?
Ecowatch Author Dan Simms

By Dan Simms

Updated 9/18/2022

Why You Can Trust EcoWatch

We work with a panel of experts to create unbiased reviews that empower you to make the right choice for your home. No other home services site has covered the root issues as long as EcoWatch, which means we’re dedicated to pointing you in a sustainable direction. Our rankings are never affected by revenue or partnerships.

Gutter guards are a great way to maintain your gutters, but some gutter types aren’t meant to accommodate heavy water flow. These types can get overwhelmed by intense rainfall and spill water over the sides, rendering your gutters useless. 

In this guide to the best gutter guards for heavy rain, we’ll discuss which gutter guards can handle the rain while keeping debris buildup out of your gutters.

These companies provide guard installation and a better product that catches smaller debris and can handle even the most intense of downpours:

  • Best Overall: LeafFilter
  • Most Versatile Design: HomeCraft Gutter Protection
  • Most Eco-Friendly Materials: MasterShield
  • Most Customizable: All American Gutter Protection
Dedicated to Sustainability
Badge icon

Ecowatch rating

Average cost

$$$$$

LeafFilter

  • Pros icon Made from sustainable and/or recycled materials
  • Pros icon Materials are recyclable
  • Pros icon Positive online reviews
  • Pros icon Has green initiatives
  • Pros icon Competitive pricing
  • Con icon Not DIY-friendly
Most Eco-Friendly Materials
Badge icon

Ecowatch rating

Average cost

$$$$$

MasterShield

  • Pros icon Made from sustainable and/or recycled materials
  • Pros icon Materials are recyclable
  • Pros icon Lifetime and/or comprehensive warranty
  • Pros icon Lots of color and design options
  • Pros icon Has green initiatives
  • Con icon Expensive products or installation fees
  • Con icon Reports of clogging
  • Con icon Made of non-recyclable materials
  • Con icon Not DIY-friendly
Most Versatile Design
Badge icon

Ecowatch rating

Average cost

$$$$$

HomeCraft

  • Pros icon Offers pitched/diamond designs for better flow
  • Con icon No stated commitment to bettering the environment
  • Con icon Some negative online reviews
  • Con icon Limited availability
Most Customizable
Badge icon

Ecowatch rating

Average cost

$$$$$

All American

  • Pros icon Materials are recyclable
  • Pros icon Lifetime and/or comprehensive warranty
  • Pros icon Lots of color and design options
  • Pros icon Competitive pricing
  • Con icon Not DIY-friendly
  • Con icon No stated commitment to bettering the environment
  • Con icon Limited availability

Jump To: Top Gutter Guards for Heavy Rain | Compare the Best Gutter Guards for Heavy Rain | LeafFilter Review | HomeCraft Gutter Protection Review | MasterShield Review | All American Gutter Protection Review | Factors to Consider When Buying Gutter Guards for Heavy Rain | Our Final Take: Which Gutter Guards Are Best for Heavy Rain? | Our Gutter Guard Company Ranking & Review Methodology | FAQ

Top Gutter Guards for Heavy Rain

When choosing the right gutter guard for your home, you should base your decision on how much rainfall you think you’ll receive. The right choice can be the difference between an adequately protected foundation and severe property damage or leaks.

For areas that see heavy rain, we recommend the below brands over do-it-yourself gutter guards you can buy from retailers like Home Depot, Lowes or Amazon.

Compare the Best Gutter Guards for Heavy Rain

Brand Our Take Avg Cost Per Linear Foot Service Area Notable Features
LeafFilter Best Overall $15-$35 43 States Large service area, years of experience, highly efficient product, lifetime warranty
HomeCraft Gutter Protection Most Versatile Design $4.50-$7.75 12 States Many size and shape options for maximum efficiency, many positive customer reviews, years of experience
MasterShield  Most Eco-Friendly Materials $17-$20 Nationwide Massive service area, eco-friendly business practices and materials, great gutter guard efficiency
All American Gutter Protection Most Customizable $15-$20 13 States Many shapes, sizes and colors available, highly efficient for heavy rainfall

LeafFilter: Best Overall

leaffilter gutter heavy water review

LeafFilter manufactures one of the best-known gutter guard options in the U.S., and it has been serving customers across the country for over 15 years. 

This company’s products and services tend to be more expensive than those of other gutter guard companies, but the quality for the cost is outstanding.

LeafFilter offers unplasticized polyvinyl chloride (uPVC) and stainless steel micro mesh gutter covers that are either recyclable or made from recycled materials. These materials won’t fade or warp over time, even with exposure to UV light from the sun, heavy rainfall and moisture.

Best of all, the micro mesh filters on these guards catch virtually all debris — including small debris like pine needles — but still allow ample water flow. As such, these products are ideal for homes that experience heavy rain.

Pros

 + Recycled and recyclable materials
 + Highly efficient at directing runoff into your gutters
 + Products catch most debris
 + Many years of experience
 + Lifetime warranty
 + Large service area

Cons

 – Expensive
 – Only suitable for professional installation

Key Features

LeafFilter gutter guards are known for their ability to catch even the smallest of debris while still maintaining a great flow rate for runoff. 

As such, these gutter guards are ideal for protecting your home from abundant rain while reducing how often you need gutter cleaning services.

What Customers Say About LeafFilter

Despite the company’s size, LeafFilter still has mostly positive customer reviews online. Many of the positive reviews are from homeowners who have tried other brands of gutter guards but find that LeafFilter provides the protection and water flow they need to keep their homes safe.

HomeCraft Gutter Protection: Most Versatile Design

HomeCraft Gutter Protection also installs micro mesh gutter guards that are designed to catch most small and large debris while managing large volumes of runoff. 

Unfortunately, these products are also not suitable for DIY installation and can be a bit costly to install.

HomeCraft offers several options for gutter guards made to fit on most standard gutters, including k-style gutters and half-round gutters. It also carries covers for five-inch and six-inch gutters. 

This makes the company ideal for homeowners who have six-inch k-style gutters that can handle excessive runoff in a short amount of time.

HomeCraft doesn’t have the greatest customer service, and there have been some issues with the installation process for some customers. However, the company still has mostly positive reviews.

Pros

 + Several designs ideal for handling heavy rainfall
 + Many years of experience
 + Products fit most homes
 + Products backed by lifetime warranty
 + Catches small debris without impeding water flow

Cons

 – No sustainable business practices
 – Some issues with customer service
 – Not suitable for DIY installation

Key Features

HomeCraft gutter guards are great for heavy rain, as the micro mesh design provides plenty of room to let water flow through while still catching most debris. 

Additionally, the variety of size and shape options lets you customize for less-common gutter styles that are already designed to manage excessive runoff.

What Customers Say About HomeCraft Gutter Protection

There have been some customer issues with HomeCraft, specifically regarding communication issues within the company that can lead to delayed installations and unprepared installation crews. 

However, most customers are pleased with how well these gutter guards themselves perform.

MasterShield: Most Eco-Friendly Materials

MasterShield frequently ranks as one of our top picks for gutter guards because the company is so committed to reducing its carbon footprint. It recycles existing gutters and covers when possible and makes its new guards with almost entirely recycled materials.

MasterShield backs its steel and aluminum gutter guards with a lifetime warranty and guarantees no clogs for life. It vows to pay for gutter cleaning if you ever need the service while its guards are installed. As such, it delivers maximum peace of mind.

The company also includes a line of copper products that helps ward off moss and algae — a particular concern in humid climates that experience heavy rain. 

The copper products help to reduce the organic material that can build up in your gutters over time, helping to avoid clogs and diminishing performance.

Pros

 + Ideal for keeping away algae and moss
 + Micro mesh design catches all debris
 + Lifetime warranty and no-clog guarantee
 + Products made from recycled materials
 + Easy installation makes this a possible DIY home improvement project

Cons

 – More expensive than most DIY options
 – Warranty only provided if installed by professionals

Key Features

MasterShield’s claim to fame is the copper technology that helps avoid gutter clogs caused by mildew, moss and algae. The company is also revered for its eco-friendly approach to gutter covers, as well as the outstanding warranty it provides.

What Customers Say About MasterShield

The reviews for MasterShield are mostly positive. Many customers specifically point out that the gutters protected by MasterShield covers don’t overflow even during excessive rain. 

The quality and length of the warranty provided are also frequently mentioned in positive reviews.

All American Gutter Protection: Most Customizable

All American Gutter Protection installs stainless steel micro mesh gutter guards on an aluminum frame. These materials are not only sturdy and long-lasting, but they’re also recyclable.

The perforations on these guards are large enough to let lots of runoff flow through them quickly, so they’re suitable for areas with above-average rainfall. The guards also get installed in line with your roof’s slope, which allows debris to fall right off of the eave from the top of the gutter.

All American is a relatively young company, but it still provides excellent customer service. The company provides a lifetime warranty on all products, and it gives you access to lots of color, size and shape options for ample customization.

Pros

 + Many gutter guard options available for matching your home
 + Excellent water flow
 + Lifetime warranty
 + Discounts available for seniors and veterans

Cons

 – Not available for DIY installation
 – Relatively small service area
 – No confirmation of eco-friendly practices

Key Features

All American gutter guards have large holes to collect a lot of rainwater quickly, but they’re small enough to keep most debris — even pine needles and leaf particles — out of your gutters and downspouts. The company makes many color and size options available, so you can match the guards to your home and the gutter size you have installed.

What Customers Say About All American Gutter Protection

All American Gutter Protection has mostly positive customer reviews online. There are many mentions made about the professionalism of the installation team and how nice it is to have customization options. 

Having options is especially valuable in areas that experience heavy rainfall, since six-inch gutters, which perform worse in heavy rain, typically aren’t as common. Since most gutter guards are made for six-inch gutters, homeowners in rainy areas might require more options.

Factors to Consider When Buying Gutter Guards for Heavy Rain

There are a few things you need to think about when buying gutter guards for a home that experiences abundant rainfall. We’ll discuss the most important things to consider below.

Gutter Guard Type & Material

First, you should look at the type of gutter guard you’re buying and the material it’s made of. 

Micro mesh gutter guards are usually best for areas with heavy rain, as the perforations can collect all of the debris while still routing all of the water into your gutter system for proper disposal.

We recommend gutter guards made out of stainless steel and aluminum as opposed to PVC as well. Metal will stand up better to extreme weather and won’t warp in response to frequent changes in moisture. 

Generally speaking, they’ll last longer and perform better in areas with above-average rainfall.

Quality

The quality of the installation service and the quality of the products installed matter a great deal as well. Improper installation can easily lead to your gutter guards failing to perform, which, in areas with heavy rain, can quickly lead to the below issues:

  • Foundation cracks
  • Structural damage
  • Leaks in your basement or crawlspace
  • Increased indoor humidity
  • More extreme indoor temperatures
  • A higher risk of pest infestation due to indoor humidity

Additionally, areas with excessive rain tend to have other extreme weather events as well, like tropical storms, hurricanes, thunderstorms and more. 

Choosing a high-quality guard made out of stainless will usually lead to a longer-lasting product in these areas.

Cost

Getting gutter guards installed professionally can be quite expensive, so you’ll want to consider the cost of the services available to you. You can ask a few installers for free quotes and compare the quality of the service and materials you’ll get for the money to find the best option.

Installation Process

Since accessing your gutters to install guards will require the use of ladders and outdoor equipment, we recommend looking at some customer reviews to see how each company handles the gutter guard installation process and cleanup.

Some companies go above and beyond to ensure they don’t damage your flower beds, lawn and other landscaping features, and they clean up all tools and debris after just a single day of work. 

Others might not be as careful, and the cleanup process could be less than impressive. Some companies might even leave tools or cutoffs on your property.

Holes, Gaps or Openings

Gutter guards contain holes or openings that allow water to flow through but prevent debris from getting into the gutter system. The size and arrangement of the perforations are what determine how well the guards work to keep debris out and how effective they are for directing runoff into your gutters.

Micro mesh gutter guards are typically best for areas that experience significant rainfall. The small perforations will keep out most debris, including small things like pine needles and pollen. 

However, they’re large enough to let water drop through them without restriction when it does rain heavily.

Maintenance

All gutter systems with gutter guards will still need occasional maintenance and gutter cleaning services. While no guards are perfect, some are far better than others at stopping debris from accumulating in your gutter system.

Here’s a brief list of the different gutter guard options available, from the most effective for keeping debris out and reducing maintenance to the least effective:

  • Micro mesh gutter guards (most effective)
  • Reverse curve gutter guards — also called surface tension guards
  • Mesh screen gutter guards
  • Foam gutter guards
  • Brush gutter guards (least effective)

We recommend opting for micro mesh gutter guards in areas with heavy rainfall, as these places typically also see the highest rate of gutter clogs due to excessive tree debris washing onto the gutters.

Warranty Coverage

Finally, we suggest you consider the warranty coverage that comes with your gutter guard system and installation process. 

Some of the best gutter guard installation companies offer lifetime warranties and even offer to pay for gutter cleaning services if you need them at any point following installation.

Areas that see heavy rainfall are also typically the same ones that experience other extreme weather. Warranty coverage keeps your equipment safe from damage — from falling tree limbs or blown debris. 

It also helps guarantee that the weather won’t cause blockages from excessive debris, which means decreased maintenance costs going forward.

We understand that it’s tempting to install your own gutter guards to save money. Aside from the challenging process, a DIY installation can actually void your roof warranty and should typically be avoided.

Here’s what happens to most homeowners who attempt a DIY gutter guard installation.

gutter guard ipswich

Our Final Take: Which Gutter Guards Are Best for Heavy Rain?

If you live in an area that sees heavy rainfall, it’s important to take some time to ensure you get guards that can handle the weather and potential debris in your area.

Our top pick for the best gutter guard for heavy rain is the micro mesh guard from LeafFilter. These guards have to be installed by professionals, but they keep virtually all debris out of your gutters and still have perforations large enough to allow heavy runoff to flow through.

Best of all, the guards from LeafFilter are made from recyclable materials, and they come with a lifetime warranty for proper functionality and durability. These heavy-duty guards are a bit on the expensive side, but most customers find that they are well worth the investment.

Check out this video to see LeafFilter gutter guards in action. 

Our Gutter Guard Company Ranking & Review Methodology

At EcoWatch, we’ve seen firsthand the negative impact clogged and overflowing gutters can have on roofs, fascia boards, soffits and, most importantly, home foundations. That’s why we take great care to bring you the most accurate information on which gutter guards are best for your home and the climate in your area.

We assess gutter guards based on many different factors. Among the most important are:

  • How well they catch debris
  • How quickly they allow water to flow into your gutters
  • How expensive they are
  • How easy they are to install
  • How extensive their warranty coverage is
  • How sustainable the materials are

Once we see how each company compares to other options in your area, we weigh each of these factors based on their relative importance.

Using this methodology, we’re able to determine the best gutter guard company for your purposes and rank each provider based on how likely they are to meet your needs and expectations.

FAQ: Gutter Guards for Heavy Rain

Blog author image

Dan Simms

Dan Simms is an experienced writer with a passion for renewable energy. As a solar and EV advocate, much of his work has focused on the potential of solar power and deregulated energy, but he also writes on related topics, like real estate and economics. In his free time — when he's not checking his own home's solar production — he enjoys outdoor activities like hiking, mountain biking, skiing and rock climbing.