28 Best Window Replacement Companies in Montauk, NY (Mar 2023)
Window Companies Near Me

Looking to improve your home's look? The top window replacement companies can help.

We analyzed all the top window installers in Montauk and selected the top 28 based on:

  • Customer reviews
  • Window replacement expertise
  • Popularity with home-owners like you
EcoWatch Local Advisors

By EcoWatch Local Advisors

Updated March 14, 2023

Why you can trust EcoWatch

Our panel of energy experts work tirelessly to create unbiased reviews and informative content to help homeowners make educated decisions. No other windows site has covered energy efficiency and sustainability as long as EcoWatch, which means we're going to help you find windows replacements that will save on your energy bill and put more money back in your wallet.

Although green energy sources like wind and solar are important when it comes to reducing your carbon footprint, improving your home's energy efficiency can also have a large impact on home energy conservation. When it's the middle of winter, your old and leaky windows could be making your home more difficult to heat and costing you more in power bills.

Installing upgraded, efficient windows on your property can help you save money each month on your electricity bills — and you can help the environment, too.

Unlike other review sites, EcoWatch ranks window installation companies on energy efficiency while also taking into consideration cost, customer satisfaction and service area.

Best Overall

Renewal by Andersen

★★★★★
4.5

  • Manufactures products in-house
  • Award-winning company
  • Member of US Green Building Council
  • No lifetime warranty

Best Affordability

Window World

★★★★★
4.5

  • Low prices relative to competitors
  • Large serice area
  • Lifetime warranty
  • Quality of service will depend on your area

Best Warranty

Universal Windows Direct

★★★★★
4

  • Wide variety of products and services
  • Manufactures products in-house
  • Lifetime warranty
  • Limited service area

Best Window Replacement Companies in Montauk

The EcoWatch Reviews team researched many window providers in Montauk to find the best ones for our readers. The installers in this article passed our review standards for energy-efficient offerings as well as customer service, local expertise, price and beyond.

Renewal by Andersen logo
FAST QUOTE
as little as 30 seconds
Best Overall

Renewal by Andersen

★★★★★
BBB Rating: A
Locations: Nationwide
Founded: 1995
Pros:
  • Pros icon Manufactures products in-house
  • Pros icon Award-winning company
  • Pros icon Member of US Green Building Council
Cons:
  • Pros icon No lifetime warranty

Renewal by Andersen is a subsidiary of the Andersen Corporation, a major manufacturer of windows and doors. This company has 27 years of experience in the window installation business, and it has established itself as one of the most respected companies in Montauk.

You may want to consider choosing Andersen if you're looking for a installer that uses in-home estimates and advanced digital tools to help you plan and visualize your project before getting started.

Energy Efficiency of Renewal by Andersen Windows

Renewal by Andersen has some Energy Star windows, but note that not all its windows are energy-efficient, so be sure to ask for Energy Star windows when inquiring. A handful of windows manufactured by the Andersen corporation were awarded Energy Star’s “Most Efficient” in 2021, and Andersen was named Energy Star’s Partner of the Year in 2019.

How much does Renewal by Andersen cost in Montauk?

Though pricing is not readily available on Andersen's website, based on customer feedback, you can expect to pay anywhere between $750 to $1,250 per window for an installation with Andersen. If you'd like more accurate information, you can ask for a quote on the company's website.

Window World logo
FAST QUOTE
as little as 30 seconds
Best Affordability

Window World

★★★★★
BBB Rating: A+
Locations: Nationwide
Founded: 1995
Pros:
  • Pros icon Low prices relative to competitors
  • Pros icon Large serice area
  • Pros icon Lifetime warranty
Cons:
  • Pros icon Quality of service will depend on your area

Window World offers windows expertise in Montauk. It's the largest window replacement company in the country, known for its vinyl windows and affordability. Window World has been in the window industry for about 27 years. Many positive reviews from customers online back the provider's reputation.

It has established itself as a company that is certified by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and Energy Star and supports charities like St. Jude Children’s Research Hospital.

Energy Efficiency of Window World Windows

Its high-performance Low-E (low-emissivity) coatings and argon gas insulation offer exceptional efficiency and performance for any home. Not all of Window World's offerings are Energy Star certified, so be sure to mention that you want Energy Star windows when inquiring.

How much does Window World cost in Montauk?

Prices aren't listed on Window World's website, but it's known for offering some of the most affordable window installations around. Receiving a free quote on its website is the best way to know for sure.

Universal Windows Direct logo
FAST QUOTE
as little as 30 seconds
Best Warranty

Universal Windows Direct

★★★★★
BBB Rating: A
Locations: Nationwide
Founded: 2002
Pros:
  • Pros icon Wide variety of products and services
  • Pros icon Manufactures products in-house
  • Pros icon Lifetime warranty
Cons:
  • Pros icon Limited service area

Universal Windows Direct offers the best warranty in Montauk. It's a company that has grown immensely since its inception in 2002, and now has several franchise dealers nationwide. This window installation company has been operating since 2002 and currently provides services to 27 states nationwide. Many positive reviews on customer review websites back the company's reputation.

It has established itself as a company that has an industry-leading warranty covering products, parts and workmanship for life.

Energy Efficiency of Universal Windows Direct Windows

Universal Windows Direct carries some Energy Star windows, but note that not all its windows are energy-efficient, so be sure to ask for high-quality Energy Star windows when inquiring. The company offers energy-efficient UniShield brand windows. According to its website, UniShield window packages have higher gas fill rates and longer gas retention than most other brands on the market, and they are Energy Star products.

How much does Universal Windows Direct cost in Montauk?

Universal does not outline prices on its website, but installations typically range from $225 to $425 per window based on customer feedback. That makes Universal Windows Direct more of a budget-friendly option for window repair and replacements. The best way to get more accurate information is to ask for a free quote from the company.

We aim to remain unbiased and transparent by including pros and cons for every company. Additionally, any partnerships do not influence our reviews.

More Window Replacement Companies in Montauk

North Shore Window Inc.

Bridgehampton, NY
4.0
★★★★★
  • Pros icon No-Hassle Pricing
  • Pros icon Dependable Service
  • Pros icon Excellent Customer Service
  • Pros icon Free Quotes

Services Offered

  • Service icon Residential Windows
  • Service icon Architectural Glass
  • Service icon Fast Delivery
  • Service icon Custom Windows
  • Service icon Aluminum Window Frames
  • Service icon Double-Hung

Website: http://northshorewindowinc.com/
Address: 48 Foster Ave #2, Bridgehampton, NY 11932
Phone: (631) 537-6400

Mr. Handyman of Norwich, New London and Glastonbury

Norwich, CT
3.9
★★★★★
  • Pros icon No-fee Quotes
  • Pros icon Dependable Service
  • Pros icon Arrives on Time
  • Pros icon Good Customer Service

Services Offered

  • Service icon Custom Windows
  • Service icon Residential Windows
  • Service icon Business Windows
  • Service icon Double-Hung

Website: https://www.mrhandyman.com/norwich-newlondon-ct/
Address: 66 Franklin St Suite 11, Norwich, CT 06360
Phone: (860) 300-3486

Clinton Glass

Clinton, CT
3.7
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Locally Recognized for Quality
  • Pros icon Free Quotes
  • Pros icon Good Customer Service
  • Pros icon Price Transparency

Services Offered

  • Service icon Residential Windows
  • Service icon Glass Showers
  • Service icon Fast Delivery
  • Service icon Custom Windows
  • Service icon Commercial Windows
  • Service icon Sliding Glass

Website: https://www.clintonglassct.com/
Address: 221 E Main St, Clinton, CT 06413
Phone: (860) 664-3711

Thomas Garbati Builders, LLC

Waterford, CT
3.7
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Price Transparency
  • Pros icon Excellent Customer Service
  • Pros icon Free Quotes
  • Pros icon Reliable Appointment Windows

Services Offered

  • Service icon Custom Windows
  • Service icon Residential Windows
  • Service icon Double-Hung

Website: http://garbatibuilders.com/
Address: 179 Butlertown Rd, Waterford, CT 06385
Phone: (860) 443-1232

Henderson Roofing

Westerly, RI
3.6
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Good Customer Service
  • Pros icon Dependable Service
  • Pros icon Educational Website
  • Pros icon Free Quotes

Services Offered

  • Service icon Custom Windows
  • Service icon Residential Windows
  • Service icon Full-Service Installations
  • Service icon Commercial Windows

Website: https://johnhendersonconstruction.com/
Address: 35 Crestview Dr, Westerly, RI 02891
Phone: (401) 208-0316

Window Wizards

Pawcatuck, CT
3.6
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Helps Educate Customers
  • Pros icon Excellent Customer Service
  • Pros icon Timely Service
  • Pros icon Dependable Service

Services Offered

  • Service icon Custom Window Designs
  • Service icon Residential Windows
  • Service icon Business Windows
  • Service icon Sliding Glass

Website: https://www.windowwizardsllc.com/
Address: Pawcatuck, CT
Phone: (860) 501-4711

Handyman Services of CT LLC

Niantic, CT
3.4
★★★★★
  • Pros icon No-Hassle Pricing
  • Pros icon Charitable Giving
  • Pros icon Helps Educate Customers
  • Pros icon Dependable Service

Services Offered

  • Service icon Custom Windows
  • Service icon Sliding Glass

Website: http://www.handymanservicesofct.com/
Address: 361 Main St #1a, Niantic, CT 06357
Phone: (860) 434-1004

Glass America

7+ years in business · Westerly, RI
3.4
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Locally Recognized for Quality
  • Pros icon Educational Website
  • Pros icon Consistent Workmanship
  • Pros icon Good Customer Service

Services Offered

  • Service icon Custom Window Designs
  • Service icon Business Windows

Website: https://www.glassusa.com/
Address: 7+ years in business · Westerly, RI
Phone: (401) 622-1182

Christopher Home Improvement

Norwich, CT
3.3
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Good Customer Service
  • Pros icon Educational Website
  • Pros icon No-fee Quotes
  • Pros icon Reliable Appointment Windows

Services Offered

  • Service icon Custom Windows
  • Service icon Residential Windows
  • Service icon Commercial Windows

Website: https://christopherimprovement.com/
Address: 16 A Winchester St, Norwich, CT 06360
Phone: (860) 381-9336

Wallace Design Center

Southold, NY
3.2
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Reliable Service
  • Pros icon Good Customer Service
  • Pros icon Free Quotes

Services Offered

  • Service icon Residential Windows
  • Service icon Energy-Efficient Options
  • Service icon Custom Window Designs
  • Service icon Aluminum Window Frames
  • Service icon Full-Service Installations
  • Service icon Commercial Windows
  • Service icon Sliding Glass

Website: http://www.wallacedesigncenter.com/
Address: 44500 County Rd 48, Southold, NY 11971
Phone: (631) 765-3890

Express Way Siding Repair Replacement And New Installation Long Island

Southampton, NY
3.2
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Reliable Service
  • Pros icon Timely Service
  • Pros icon No-Hassle Pricing
  • Pros icon Excellent Customer Service

Services Offered

  • Service icon Custom Windows
  • Service icon Residential Windows
  • Service icon Business Windows
  • Service icon Double-Hung

Website: http://expresswaysiding.com/
Address: 10 Oak St, Southampton, NY 11968
Phone: (631) 772-6364

Expressway Roof Leaks and Siding Repair

East Hampton, NY
3.2
★★★★★
  • Pros icon No-Hassle Pricing
  • Pros icon No-fee Quotes
  • Pros icon Dependable Service
  • Pros icon Arrives on Time

Services Offered

  • Service icon Custom Windows
  • Service icon Residential Windows
  • Service icon Full-Service Installations
  • Service icon Business Windows

Website: http://www.expresswayroofingandchimney.com/
Address: 21 Kent Pl, East Hampton, NY 11937
Phone: (631) 772-7595

Harbor Interiors Inc

Southampton, NY
3.2
★★★★★
  • Pros icon No-fee Quotes
  • Pros icon No-Hassle Pricing
  • Pros icon Good Customer Service
  • Pros icon Helps Educate Customers

Services Offered

  • Service icon Custom Windows
  • Service icon Residential Windows
  • Service icon Commercial Windows
  • Service icon Double-Hung

Website: http://www.hamptonblinds.com/
Address: 177 Fish Cove Rd, Southampton, NY 11968
Phone: (631) 283-8725

Hampton Glass & Mirror

Southampton, NY
3.0
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Free Quotes
  • Pros icon Price Transparency
  • Pros icon Reliable Service
  • Pros icon Helps Educate Customers

Services Offered

  • Service icon Custom Window Designs
  • Service icon Glass Showers
  • Service icon Architectural Glass

Website: http://www.hamptonglassonline.com/
Address: 311 County Rd 39A, Southampton, NY 11968
Phone: (631) 283-5480

J&J Rivera Home Improvement and Supply CO

Old Saybrook, CT
3.0
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Good Customer Service
  • Pros icon No-fee Quotes
  • Pros icon Price Transparency
  • Pros icon Consistent Workmanship

Services Offered

  • Service icon Custom Windows
  • Service icon Residential Windows
  • Service icon Commercial Windows

Website: http://jjriverahomeimprovementandsupplyco.com/
Address: 1790 Boston Post Rd, Old Saybrook, CT 06475
Phone: (860) 304-0851

Pane In The Glass

Westerly, RI
3.0
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Price Transparency
  • Pros icon Good Customer Service
  • Pros icon Reliable Service
  • Pros icon Free Quotes

Services Offered

  • Service icon Custom Windows
  • Service icon Residential Windows
  • Service icon Commercial Windows

Website: http://www.paneintheglasswc.com/
Address: 58 Fountain Dr, Westerly, RI 02891
Phone: (401) 477-2177

ICOR Building & Remodeling

Mystic, CT
2.9
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Arrives on Time
  • Pros icon Educational Website
  • Pros icon Good Customer Service
  • Pros icon Free Quotes

Services Offered

  • Service icon Custom Windows

Website: http://icorgc.com/
Address: 96 Rhonda Dr, Mystic, CT 06355
Phone: (860) 464-4581

Robert E Otto Glass Inc.

Wainscott, NY
2.9
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Helps Educate Customers
  • Pros icon Good Customer Service
  • Pros icon Price Transparency
  • Pros icon Free Quotes

Services Offered

  • Service icon Custom Windows
  • Service icon Aluminum Window Frames
  • Service icon Architectural Glass
  • Service icon Sliding Glass

Website: http://www.robertottoglass.com/
Address: 350 Montauk Hwy, Wainscott, NY 11975
Phone: (631) 537-1515

HAMPTONS CEDAR DESIGN.COM

East Hampton, NY
2.7
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Good Customer Service
  • Pros icon Helps Educate Customers
  • Pros icon No-fee Quotes
  • Pros icon No-Hassle Pricing

Services Offered

  • Service icon Custom Window Designs
  • Service icon Residential Windows
  • Service icon Business Windows

Website: http://hamptonscedardesign.com/
Address: 81 Newtown Ln #346, East Hampton, NY 11937
Phone: (631) 637-2828

Jean Mirror & Glass

Montville, CT
2.6
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Educational Website
  • Pros icon Free Quotes
  • Pros icon No-Hassle Pricing

Services Offered

  • Service icon Custom Window Designs
  • Service icon Glass Showers
  • Service icon Commercial Windows
  • Service icon Double-Hung

Website: https://jeanmirrorandglass.com/
Address: 4 Bridge St Garage Bay 7, Montville, CT 06353
Phone: (860) 848-4527

All Time Manufacturing Company, Inc.

Montville, CT
2.4
★★★★★
  • Pros icon No-Hassle Pricing
  • Pros icon Good Customer Service

Services Offered

  • Service icon Residential Windows
  • Service icon Architectural Glass
  • Service icon Custom Windows
  • Service icon Aluminum Window Frames
  • Service icon Commercial Windows

Website: http://www.alltimemfg.com/
Address: 284 CT-163, Montville, CT 06353
Phone: (860) 848-9258

Westerly Glass

Westerly, RI
2.4
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Educational Website
  • Pros icon Excellent Customer Service
  • Pros icon No-fee Quotes
  • Pros icon Price Transparency

Services Offered

  • Service icon Custom Windows
  • Service icon Sliding Glass

Website: http://westerlyglassco.com/
Address: 2 Industrial Dr, Westerly, RI 02891
Phone: (401) 596-4733

Yost Home Improvements, Inc.

CT-85, CT
2.3
★★★★★
  • Pros icon No-fee Quotes
  • Pros icon Educational Website
  • Pros icon Excellent Customer Service

Services Offered

  • Service icon Custom Windows
  • Service icon Energy-Efficient Options
  • Service icon Architectural Glass

Website: http://yosthomeimprovements.com/
Address: 1018 Hartford Turnpike, CT-85, Waterford, CT 06385
Phone: (860) 442-8032

Windor Inc

Charlestown, RI
2.3
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Consistent Workmanship
  • Pros icon Price Transparency
  • Pros icon Free Quotes

Services Offered

  • Service icon Custom Windows
  • Service icon Aluminum Window Frames
  • Service icon Sliding Glass

Website: http://www.windorman.com/
Address: 3856 Old Post Rd, Charlestown, RI 02813
Phone: (401) 364-7579

Calvary Remodeling

Mystic, CT
2.2
★★★★★
  • Pros icon No-Hassle Pricing
  • Pros icon Free Quotes
  • Pros icon Excellent Customer Service
  • Pros icon Educational Website

Services Offered

  • Service icon Custom Window Designs

Website: https://calvaryremodeling.com/
Address: 34 Greenmanville Ave, Mystic, CT 06355
Phone: (203) 443-2421

Panorama Glass and Mirror

Hampton Bays, NY
2.1
★★★★★
  • Pros icon No-Hassle Pricing

Services Offered

  • Service icon Architectural Glass
  • Service icon Tempered Glass
  • Service icon Custom Windows
  • Service icon Aluminum Window Frames
  • Service icon Full-Service Installations

Website: http://www.panoramaglassandmirror.com/
Address: 276 W Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays, NY 11946
Phone: (631) 728-3919

NSE Windows

Water Mill, NY
1.9
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Excellent Customer Service
  • Pros icon No-Hassle Pricing
  • Pros icon Educational Website

Services Offered

  • Service icon Custom Window Designs

Website: http://nsewindows.com/
Address: 734 Montauk Hwy, Water Mill, NY 11976
Phone: (516) 500-3550

Giovanni & Sons Construction

Westerly, RI
1.8
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Price Transparency
  • Pros icon Free Quotes

Services Offered

  • Service icon Custom Window Designs
  • Service icon Commercial Windows

Website: http://giovanniandsons.com/
Address: 140 Main St, Westerly, RI 02891
Phone: (401) 212-9336

How Installing Energy-Efficient Windows in Montauk Saves You Money

When you switch to energy-efficient windows, you may see several benefits, such as:

  • Save on power bills: Installing energy-efficient windows reduces your energy bills by about 12% since you need less energy.
  • Protect your investment: If you have an older home, your windows are most likely in need of replacement. Upgrading your windows can make your home more comfortable and also help raise the value of your house if you decide to sell.
  • Decrease your carbon footprint: Since energy-efficient windows improve the insulation in your house, you can cut your carbon footprint by about 12%, according to Energy Star.
  • Protect your valuables: The low-emissivity coatings on many energy-efficient windows help prevent your floors, carpets and furniture from fading by filtering out UV rays.

Estimated Cost of Window Replacement in Montauk

Windows come in different shapes and sizes, so costs and services will differ greatly. Here are the typical costs and services that you'll find from window installation companies.

How Much Do New Windows Cost?

According to our market research, the average cost of replacing a single window is around $600. However, window installation costs can range from $200 to $1,200 per window. Costs will vary considerably based on the number of windows you need, the quality of your products, your location and the current condition of your home. Many window companies also offer door installations and other add-ons like coating, baths, shutters and more. These extra services will increase your overall project costs.

Whether or not you choose energy-efficient windows is another factor that will influence the cost. These will usually cost more than other windows, but on the other hand, you can save about $215 a year on your energy bills in Montauk.

How much your window installation costs will also vary based on the type of material you choose for the frames. Wood windows are generally the most expensive, but it depends if they are 100% wood or clad with aluminum or vinyl. Fiberglass windows also tend to be somewhat more expensive than vinyl, but they are shown to be more efficient.

What Services do Window Installers Offer?

The first question to ask yourself when planning on installing new windows is: Should you get a full-frame installation or a pocket installation?

A full-frame installation is a replacement of the full window. It involves removing the old window, the sill, and the exterior and interior trim. It can also involve additional materials, including insulation and drip edges, which increase the overall cost of the project. Also worth noting: you may have to touch up the paint around the window after a full-frame installation. A pocket installation means replacing a window without removing the entire frame, which tends to be cheaper than a full-frame installation.

If you're hiring a reputable window installation company, your company will be able to recommend the best type for your project. In Montauk, the decision will mostly be based on the efficiency of your home and how old your existing frames are.

Best Overall

Renewal by Andersen

★★★★★
4.5

  • Manufactures products in-house
  • Award-winning company
  • Member of US Green Building Council
  • No lifetime warranty

Best Affordability

Window World

★★★★★
4.5

  • Low prices relative to competitors
  • Large serice area
  • Lifetime warranty
  • Quality of service will depend on your area

Best Warranty

Universal Windows Direct

★★★★★
4

  • Wide variety of products and services
  • Manufactures products in-house
  • Lifetime warranty
  • Limited service area

How We Choose the Best Window Installers in Montauk

In our search to find the most reliable, eco-friendly window installers in Montauk, the EcoWatch Reviews team chose the above companies as the top window installation companies in the city. Along with energy efficiency, we reviewed window companies all across the state and ranked them based on the following methodology:

Service Area

Because this is a guide for Montauk, we paid more attention to companies that cover the city. There are other reputable providers that didn't make the cut because of the low odds that they would serve the average homeowner in Montauk.

Work Quality

When installing new windows, the quality and range of services often plays just as important of a role in insulation and performance as the brand you opt for. We do rate window installers higher if they offer high-quality products, but we also consider workmanship as reflected in customer feedback.

Customer Reviews

Another self-explanatory yet super important review factor is customer feedback. If the majority of customers don't have positive things to say about their service from a certain company, it won't be featured on EcoWatch.

Cost

Cheaper windows don't necessarily mean better windows, but we know many of our readers try to keep costs as low as possible. When analyzing the prices of providers, we awarded higher points to companies with reasonable prices and accessible financing rather than "cheaper" services.

Warranty

As discussed, windows are a sizable investment, so you'll want to be certain that investment is protected. Window installation companies that offer lengthy warranties for products, parts and installation (aka workmanship) rank higher with EcoWatch.

Years of Experience

Because of Montauk's climate, homeowners will want to mitigate low efficiency, rot and water damage. We factored in local experience to reflect the ability of Montauk window companies to prepare homes for the climate. If a company has less than 10 years of experience, it loses points in this category.

Montauk, NY Window Replacement FAQs

What is the typical cost to install windows?

The national average cost of replacing one window is about $600 but can range between $200 and $1,200, based on a variety of factors. The price is often dependent on the location of your property, the size of the window and the type and material of the window. Also, remember that energy-efficient windows may cost more initially but can save you a decent amount of money a year in energy bills.

Which type of window should I get?

A window's energy efficiency is affected by several factors, such as the quality of the installation and what kind of window it is. Look for Energy Star Certified windows — these are typically the most energy-efficient since they are certified by the U.S. Department of Energy.

Do you really need to use a window installation company?

You should hire a window installation professional whenever you need to upgrade your windows. Installing windows is a involved process that can be difficult and time-consuming, so it's best left to the professionals.

What time of year should I replace my windows?

Replacement windows can be installed during any season, but autumn might be best. Regardless of when you install them, the contractors will take steps to make sure that too much hot or cold air doesn't get into your house, so the temperature outside doesn't necessarily matter that much. What's most important is that the weather should be dry.

How often should you replace windows?

Windows have a typical lifespan of about 20 to 30 years. If your windows are older than that, then they should probably be replaced. Other than that, if your windows have any damage on them, or they have become difficult to operate, they may need to be replaced.

Follow us