20 Best Window Companies in New Castle, IN (2025 Reviews)
Looking to improve your house’s insulation? The best window replacement companies can help.
We analyzed all the top-rated window companies in New Castle and selected the best 20 based on:
Customer reviews
Window installation expertise
Popularity with home-owners like you
Please enter a valid 5-digit zip code!
Why you can trust EcoWatch
Although green energy sources like wind and solar are important when it comes to decreasing your carbon footprint, improving your house’s efficiency can also have a big impact on home energy conservation. Potential leaks or drafts can decrease your home’s energy efficiency by up to 30%, according to the Department of Energy. In New Castle, that’s an average of $362 per year that you could save on your power bills by making the switch.
That’s bad for both your wallet and the environment, but one of the best window installation companies can help with that.
As windows are so important for your home, choosing the right company for you is a big decision to make. That’s why the EcoWatch team has made this list of the top window replacement companies, so you can more easily make an informed decision.
Best Availability
Renewal by Andersen
- Great Industry Reputation
- Award-winning Company
- Member of US Green Building Council
- Manufactures products in-house
Best Energy-Efficient Features
Champion
- Many years of experience
- Low prices relative to competitors
- Limetime warranty
Power Home
- Uses eco-friendly materials
- Well-trained, certified installers
- Lifetime or lengthy warranty
Best Window Installation & Replacement Companies in New Castle
The EcoWatch Reviews team assessed dozens of installers in New Castle to find the top window replacement companies for our readers. The companies in this article scored best in our review categories, such as energy-efficient offerings, local expertise, availability, customer service, price and more.

Window World
EnergyStar Partner
Large serice area
Low prices relative to competitors
Great industry reputation
Lifetime warranty
Quality of service will depend on your area
Window World offers windows expertise in New Castle. Window World has been in the window industry for around 27 years. The company has plenty of glowing reviews from customers on online review websites.
Window World may be the company for you if you want one that is certified by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and Energy Star and supports charities like St. Jude Children’s Research Hospital.
Energy Efficiency of Window World WindowsIts high-performance Low-E (low-emissivity) coatings and argon gas insulation offer exceptional efficiency and performance for any home. Not all of Window World’s windows are Energy Star certified, so be sure to mention that you’re interested in Energy Star windows when inquiring.
How much does Window World cost in New Castle?Prices aren’t displayed on Window World’s website, but it's known for offering some of the most affordable window installations around. The best way to get more accurate information is to ask for a free quote from the company.

Renewal by Andersen
Great industry reputation
Award-winning company
Member of US Green Building Council
Manufactures products in-house
No lifetime warranty
More expensive than competition
Renewal by Andersen offers the best availability in New Castle. Andersen has been in the window industry for around 27 years. The company has plenty of glowing reviews from customers on online review websites.
Andersen may be the company for you if you want one that uses in-home estimates and advanced digital tools to help you plan and visualize your project before getting started.
Energy Efficiency of Renewal by Andersen WindowsA handful of windows manufactured by the Andersen corporation were awarded Energy Star’s “Most Efficient” in 2021, and Andersen was named Energy Star’s Partner of the Year in 2019. Not all of Andersen’s windows are Energy Star certified, so be sure to mention that you’re interested in Energy Star windows when inquiring.
How much does Renewal by Andersen cost in New Castle?Prices aren’t displayed on Andersen’s website, but based on customer feedback, you can expect to pay anywhere between $750 to $1,250 per window for an installation with Andersen. The best way to get more accurate information is to ask for a free quote from the company.

Window Nation
Award-winning company
Manufactures products in-house
Custom designs
Wide variety of products and services
Installation not covered by warranty
Limited service area
Window Nation offers the best residential windows in New Castle. Window Nation has been in the window industry for around 16 years. The company has plenty of glowing reviews from customers on online review websites.
Window Nation may be the company for you if you want one that gives customers the opportunity to view products and to speak to a representative in person in its showrooms.
Energy Efficiency of Window Nation WindowsEach product has windowpanes coated with a Low-E (low emissivity) glaze that prevents damaging UV rays from heating your home. Plus, the spaces between double- and triple-pane windows are filled with argon gas that’s been proven to improve home insulation. Not all of Window Nation’s windows are Energy Star certified, so be sure to mention that you’re interested in Energy Star windows when inquiring.
How much does Window Nation cost in New Castle?Prices aren’t displayed on Window Nation’s website, but based on customer feedback, you can expect to pay between $300 and $525 per window installed, making it a more affordable option compared to competitors. The best way to get more accurate information is to ask for a free quote from the company.
Please note that the companies in this section are national, which means the quality of the service may vary depending on your local crew. We have tried to stay unbiased and transparent by including pros and cons for every company.
More Window Companies in New Castle
Champion Replacement Windows of Indianapolis
Indianapolis, INGood Customer Service
Price Transparency
Free assessment
Services Offered
Bay Windows
Window Replacement/Installation
Glass Doors
Double-Hung
Window Nation
Indianapolis, INGood Customer Service
Free assessment
Price Transparency
Educational Website
Services Offered
Energy-Efficient Options
Bay Windows
Custom Window Designs
Glass Doors
Double-Hung
Vinyl Frames
Window Replacement/Installation
Screenmobile of East-Central Indiana
New Castle, INFree assessment
Good Customer Service
Educational Website
Services Offered
Screen Repair
Custom Window Designs
Glass Doors
Window Replacement/Installation
LYON, Inc.
Indianapolis, INPrice Transparency
Free assessment
Services Offered
Glass Showers
Window Replacement/Installation
Bay Windows
Outer Limits Construction Co
Greenwood, INPrice Transparency
Timely Service
Services Offered
Window Replacement/Installation
Budget Blinds of Muncie and Noblesville
Muncie, INEducational Website
Free assessment
Timely Service
Good Customer Service
Services Offered
Energy-Efficient Options
Window Replacement/Installation
Custom Window Designs
Surber's Windows and Doors
Anderson, INFree assessment
Price Transparency
Good Customer Service
Services Offered
Energy-Efficient Options
Glass Doors
Vinyl Frames
Double-Hung
Window Replacement/Installation
Glass Showers
L.J. Stone, Inc. - Baths, Showers, Windows, Doors and Patio Covers
Muncie, INFree assessment
Good Customer Service
Timely Service
Educational Website
Price Transparency
Services Offered
Glass Doors
Window Replacement/Installation
Double-Hung
Bay Windows
Glass Showers
Fadely Home Design
Fishers, INFree assessment
Price Transparency
Educational Website
Services Offered
Window Replacement/Installation
Vinyl Frames
Overhead Door Co. of Indianapolis
Indianapolis, INFree assessment
Price Transparency
Good Customer Service
Educational Website
Services Offered
Bay Windows
Window Replacement/Installation
Glass Doors
Energy-Efficient Options
Double-Hung
Window Repair
Vinyl Frames
The Glass Guru
Fishers, INGood Customer Service
Free assessment
Educational Website
Services Offered
Vinyl Frames
Skylights
Glass Doors
Fiberglass Frames
Glass Showers
Custom Glass
Tempered Glass
Metal Frames
Mirrors
Energy-Efficient Options
Window Repair
Screen Repair
Glass Repair
Storm/Impact Windows
Triple Pane Glass
Window Replacement/Installation
Wood Frames
Window Consultants of Indiana
Carmel, INEducational Website
Free assessment
Price Transparency
Timely Service
Services Offered
Energy-Efficient Options
Wood Frames
Window Replacement/Installation
Window Repair
Storm/Impact Windows
Window Depot USA of Indianapolis
Indianapolis, INGood Customer Service
Educational Website
Price Transparency
Free assessment
Timely Service
Services Offered
Glass Doors
Energy-Efficient Options
Vinyl Frames
Triple Pane Glass
Window Replacement/Installation
Bay Windows
Double-Hung
Wood Frames
True Crew Windows and Doors
Muncie, INFree assessment
Educational Website
Price Transparency
Services Offered
Window Replacement/Installation
Glass Doors
Energy-Efficient Options
Custom Window Designs
Window World of Muncie
Muncie, INGood Customer Service
Free assessment
Price Transparency
Educational Website
Services Offered
Window Replacement/Installation
Glass Doors
Bay Windows
Double-Hung
Northside Glass & Mirror
Indianapolis, INFree assessment
Services Offered
Mirrors
Custom Glass
Window Replacement/Installation
Glass Showers
Stronghold Glass
Bluffton, INEducational Website
Good Customer Service
Price Transparency
Free assessment
Services Offered
Glass Repair
Glass Showers
Mirrors
Window Replacement/Installation
Vinyl Frames
Glass Doctor of Indianapolis
Indianapolis, INGood Customer Service
Price Transparency
Educational Website
Services Offered
Energy-Efficient Options
Window Replacement/Installation
Glass Repair
Window Repair
Glass Showers
Custom Glass
Mirrors
Apex Energy Solutions
Zionsville, INEducational Website
Free assessment
Good Customer Service
Services Offered
Energy-Efficient Options
Window Replacement/Installation
Gut R Dun Exteriors
Moraine, OHEducational Website
Good Customer Service
Free assessment
Price Transparency
Services Offered
Window Replacement/Installation
Calculate how much you can expect to pay for window installation and replacement in New Castle, IN using our customized window cost calculator.
Estimates will vary based on window dimensions and other unique factors to your home. Getting in touch with a local window installer is the best way to get an accurate cost estimate for your home.
How Installing Energy-Efficient Windows in New Castle Saves You Money
There are quite a few perks of upgrading to energy-efficient windows. Some reasons you may want to consider making the change include the following:
- Protect your investment: Keeping your windows up to date is an important part of maintaining your property and its real estate value, especially if your home is on the older side.
- Protect your valuables: The low-emissivity coatings on many Energy Star certified windows help prevent your floors, carpets and furniture from fading by filtering out UV rays.
- Decrease your carbon footprint: Reducing the amount of energy you use also lowers your carbon emissions. You could reduce it by about 622 pounds.
- Save money on energy bills: Since energy-efficient windows reduce the amount of energy used to heat or cool your home, they can help you save about $362 annually on your energy bills in New Castle.
Estimated Cost of Window Replacement in New Castle
Each window installer provides various services and has different costs depending on several factors.
How Much Do New Windows Cost?
The average cost to install one window is about $600 but can range from $200 to $1,200. How much it will cost is based on several factors, like size, number of windows, type, the location of your home, material and more.
With windows, efficiency is one of the most important factors for most homeowners. Efficient windows may cost more initially, but by increasing the efficiency of your home — especially during the summer and winter — they can provide decades of energy savings. According to Energy Star, purchasing certified energy-efficient windows can save New Castle homeowners $362+ each year after replacing single-pane windows.
We recommend requesting free quotes from multiple window installers to find the right windows and the company that works best for your budget.
What Services do Window Installers Offer?
The first step when planning a replacement is to figure out whether you want a full-frame or pocket installation.
A full-frame installation is a total window replacement. It involves removing the old window, the windowsill, and the exterior and interior trim. It also involves extra materials, including insulation and drip edges, which raise the overall cost of the project. It’s also worth noting that it’s not uncommon for homeowners to have to touch up the paint surrounding the window after a full-frame installation. Pocket installations are on the simpler end and won’t carry as large a bill, as they involve merely replacing the window within its existing frame. But if the frame has any damage, you should opt for a full-frame installation instead.
Your window replacement company will be able to help you decide what’s best for your needs. In New Castle, the decision will mostly be based on the age of your windows and if there’s any moisture damage. Wood can decay if it’s not maintained properly over the years, so it’s good to have a professional check your frames and window sills.
Best Availability
Renewal by Andersen
- Great Industry Reputation
- Award-winning Company
- Member of US Green Building Council
- Manufactures products in-house
Best Energy-Efficient Features
Champion
- Many years of experience
- Low prices relative to competitors
- Limetime warranty
Power Home
- Uses eco-friendly materials
- Well-trained, certified installers
- Lifetime or lengthy warranty
How We Choose the Best Window Installers in New Castle
In our search to make your home improvements easier and more eco-friendly in New Castle, the EcoWatch Reviews team evaluated many companies before landing on these. Along with energy efficiency, we evaluated window companies all across the state and assigned rankings based on the following methodology:
Service Area
This one is pretty self-explanatory, but we’ve chosen to highlight window installation companies that serve a wide variety of states and cities so you can find the best window installation company near you.
Work Quality
When installing new windows, the quality and range of services often plays just as important of a role in overall efficiency and performance as the brand you opt for. We do give window installers more points if they offer high-quality products, but we also consider workmanship as reflected in customer feedback.
Customer Reviews
We analyzed trends in recent customer feedback to determine the companies with the highest rates of customer satisfaction, weighted by sample size. Customer satisfaction may be the factor we place the most value on, as it reflects the quality of services across most other categories, including quality of installation, quality of parts, professionalism, warranty, cost and more.
Cost
This one is a give-and-take: similar to other services, cheap window installation companies won’t always provide the highest quality service. Still, we want to ensure we’re highlighting companies that offer a range of price and financing options so they’re accessible to most homeowners.
Warranty
Protecting your investment in new windows is important to many homeowners. For that reason, window installation companies that give you lengthy warranties for products, parts and installation (aka workmanship) rank higher with EcoWatch.
Years of Experience
Lastly, we like to see companies that have a good track record in the industry. Window installation companies that have more experience earn higher rankings by our standards. We like to see at least ten years of experience.
New Castle, IN Window Replacement FAQs
How much does window installation cost?
The average cost to install one window can range between $450 and $650. There are several factors that affect the cost, which include styles and sizes of windows, how energy-efficient the windows are, your property’s location, the materials used in designing the windows, the number of windows and local labor costs.
What are the most common kinds of replacement windows?
The most common kinds of windows for homes are awning windows, double-hung and single-hung windows, transom windows, casement windows, bay windows, picture windows and slider windows.
What services do window installation companies offer?
Window installation companies cover the entire process — from replacing old windows with new ones to cleaning up after the installation. In addition, some companies offer window manufacturing, customization and repairs.
Should I replace all my windows at once?
If your windows are more than 20 years old, you most likely need to replace all of them. At that point, they are typically less efficient, draftier and/or more damaged than new windows. Replacing your windows all at once will involve less paperwork and less time.