20 Best Window Companies in New Castle, IN (2024 Reviews)

Looking to improve your house’s insulation? The best window replacement companies can help.

We analyzed all the top-rated window companies in New Castle and selected the best 20 based on:

  • Customer reviews
  • Window installation expertise
  • Popularity with home-owners like you
EcoWatch Local Advisors

By EcoWatch Local Advisors

Updated April 21, 2024

Why you can trust EcoWatch

Our panel of energy experts work tirelessly to create unbiased reviews and informative content to help homeowners make educated decisions. No other windows site has covered energy efficiency and sustainability as long as EcoWatch, which means we're going to help you find windows replacements that will save on your energy bill and put more money back in your wallet.

Although green energy sources like wind and solar are important when it comes to decreasing your carbon footprint, improving your house’s efficiency can also have a big impact on home energy conservation. Potential leaks or drafts can decrease your home’s energy efficiency by up to 30%, according to the Department of Energy. In New Castle, that’s almost $362 per year that you could save on your power bills by making the switch.

Luckily, saving you energy with upgraded windows also aligns with our goals of reducing energy usage for the environment.

So if you’re constructing a new home, renovating or updating your windows in New Castle, this guide is the best place to get started.

Best Availability

Renewal by Andersen

★★★★★
4.5
  • Great industry reputation
  • Member of US Green Building Council
  • Manufactures products in-house
Buy One Window, Get One 40% OFF
Get Estimate

Best Energy-Efficient Features

Champion

★★★★★
4.5
  • Many years of experience
  • Low prices relative to competitors
  • Limetime warranty
Buy 2 Windows, Get 2 Free
Get Estimate

Power Home

★★★★★
4.5
  • Uses eco-friendly materials
  • Well-trained, certified installers
  • Lifetime or lengthy warranty
Next-Day Appointments Available
Get Estimate

Best Window Installation & Replacement Companies in New Castle

The EcoWatch Reviews team assessed dozens of installers across the country to find the best window replacement companies for our readers. The installers in this article scored best in our review categories, such as energy-efficient offerings, price, customer service, availability, local expertise and more.

Window World logo
FAST QUOTE
as little as 30 seconds
Best Affordability

Window World

★★★★★
BBB Rating: A+
Locations: Nationwide
Founded: 1995
Pros:
  • Pros icon EnergyStar Partner
  • Pros icon Large serice area
  • Pros icon Low prices relative to competitors
  • Pros icon Great industry reputation
  • Pros icon Lifetime warranty
Cons:
  • Pros icon Quality of service will depend on your area

Window World offers windows expertise in New Castle. This company has been operating since 1995 and currently services 200 locations nationwide. Its reputation is backed by several positive reviews on customer review websites.

You may want to consider choosing Window World if you're looking for a company that is certified by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and Energy Star and supports charities like St. Jude Children’s Research Hospital.

Energy Efficiency of Window World Windows

Its high-performance Low-E (low-emissivity) coatings and argon gas insulation offer exceptional efficiency and performance for any home. Not all of Window World’s windows are Energy Star certified, so make sure you mention that you’d like Energy Star windows when inquiring.

How much does Window World cost in New Castle?

Pricing information is not available on Window World’s website since the cost of window installment differs based on how many and what type(s) of windows you need. However, it's known for offering some of the most affordable window installations around. You can inquire about a free quote on its website for more information about the cost.

Renewal by Andersen logo
FAST QUOTE
as little as 30 seconds
Best Overall

Renewal by Andersen

★★★★★
BBB Rating: A
Locations: Nationwide
Founded: 1995
Pros:
  • Pros icon Great industry reputation
  • Pros icon Award-winning company
  • Pros icon Member of US Green Building Council
  • Pros icon Manufactures products in-house
Cons:
  • Pros icon No lifetime warranty
  • Pros icon More expensive than competition

Renewal by Andersen offers the best availability in New Castle. This company has been operating since 1995 and currently services nearly every state except Mississippi and West Virginia. Its reputation is backed by several positive reviews on customer review websites.

You may want to consider choosing Andersen if you're looking for a company that uses in-home estimates and advanced digital tools to help you plan and visualize your project before getting started.

Energy Efficiency of Renewal by Andersen Windows

A handful of windows manufactured by the Andersen corporation were awarded Energy Star’s “Most Efficient” in 2021, and Andersen was named Energy Star’s Partner of the Year in 2019. Not all of Andersen’s windows are Energy Star certified, so make sure you mention that you’d like Energy Star windows when inquiring.

How much does Renewal by Andersen cost in New Castle?

Pricing information is not available on Andersen’s website since the cost of window installment differs based on how many and what type(s) of windows you need. However, based on customer feedback, you can expect to pay anywhere between $750 to $1,250 per window for an installation with Andersen. You can inquire about a free quote on its website for more information about the cost.

Universal Windows Direct logo
FAST QUOTE
as little as 30 seconds
Best Warranty

Universal Windows Direct

★★★★★
BBB Rating: A
Locations: Nationwide
Founded: 2002
Pros:
  • Pros icon Makes charitable contributions
  • Pros icon Manufactures products in-house
  • Pros icon Wide variety of products and services
  • Pros icon Lifetime warranty
Cons:
  • Pros icon Limited service area
  • Pros icon Some installations carried out by third-party contractors
  • Pros icon Quality of service will depend on your area

Universal Windows Direct offers the best warranty in New Castle. This company has been operating since 2002 and currently services 27 states nationwide. Its reputation is backed by several positive reviews on customer review websites.

You may want to consider choosing Universal if you're looking for a company that has an industry-leading warranty covering products, parts and workmanship for life.

Energy Efficiency of Universal Windows Direct Windows

The company offers energy-efficient UniShield brand windows. According to its website, UniShield window packages have higher gas fill rates and longer gas retention than most other brands on the market, and they are Energy Star products. Not all of Universal’s windows are Energy Star certified, so make sure you mention that you’d like Energy Star windows when inquiring.

How much does Universal Windows Direct cost in New Castle?

Pricing information is not available on Universal’s website since the cost of window installment differs based on how many and what type(s) of windows you need. However, installations typically range from $225 to $425 per window based on customer feedback. That makes Universal Windows Direct more of a budget-friendly option for window repair and replacements. You can inquire about a free quote on its website for more information about the cost.

Window Nation logo
FAST QUOTE
as little as 30 seconds
Best for Residential Windows

Window Nation

★★★★★
BBB Rating: A
Locations: Regional
Founded: 2006
Pros:
  • Pros icon Award-winning company
  • Pros icon Manufactures products in-house
  • Pros icon Custom designs
  • Pros icon Wide variety of products and services
Cons:
  • Pros icon Installation not covered by warranty
  • Pros icon Limited service area

Window Nation offers the best residential windows in New Castle. This company has been operating since 2006 and currently services residents within 75 miles of its showrooms, which are in 13 states. Its reputation is backed by several positive reviews on customer review websites.

You may want to consider choosing Window Nation if you're looking for a company that gives customers the opportunity to view products and to speak to a representative in person in its showrooms.

Energy Efficiency of Window Nation Windows

Each product has windowpanes coated with a Low-E (low emissivity) glaze that prevents damaging UV rays from heating your home. Plus, the spaces between double- and triple-pane windows are filled with argon gas that’s been proven to improve home insulation. Not all of Window Nation’s windows are Energy Star certified, so make sure you mention that you’d like Energy Star windows when inquiring.

How much does Window Nation cost in New Castle?

Pricing information is not available on Window Nation’s website since the cost of window installment differs based on how many and what type(s) of windows you need. However, based on customer feedback, you can expect to pay between $300 and $525 per window installed, making it a more affordable option compared to competitors. You can inquire about a free quote on its website for more information about the cost.

We’ve recommended companies with shining reputations, but note that these are national companies, so your service may depend on your local crew. We have tried to remain unbiased and transparent by including pros and cons for each company we reviewed.

More Window Companies in New Castle

Champion Replacement Windows of Indianapolis

Indianapolis, IN
4.2
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Good Customer Service
  • Pros icon Free assessment
  • Pros icon Price Transparency

Services Offered

  • Service icon Window Replacement/Installation
  • Service icon Bay Windows
  • Service icon Glass Doors
  • Service icon Double-Hung

Website: https://www.championwindow.com/Indianapolis/
Address: 1435 Brookville Way Suite E, Indianapolis, IN 46239
Phone: (317) 608-0661

Window World of Muncie

Muncie, IN
4.8
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Price Transparency
  • Pros icon Free assessment
  • Pros icon Educational Website
  • Pros icon Good Customer Service

Services Offered

  • Service icon Double-Hung
  • Service icon Bay Windows
  • Service icon Glass Doors
  • Service icon Window Replacement/Installation

Website: https://www.windowworldmuncie.com/
Address: 3508 Wheeling Ave, Muncie, IN 47304
Phone: (765) 281-0008

Window Nation

Indianapolis, IN
4.5
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Price Transparency
  • Pros icon Free assessment
  • Pros icon Educational Website
  • Pros icon Good Customer Service

Services Offered

  • Service icon Window Replacement/Installation
  • Service icon Bay Windows
  • Service icon Glass Doors
  • Service icon Double-Hung
  • Service icon Custom Window Designs
  • Service icon Vinyl Frames
  • Service icon Energy-Efficient Options

Website: https://www.windownation.com/indianapolis-showroom/
Address: 2040 S Lynhurst Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46241
Phone: (317) 829-9884

Screenmobile of East-Central Indiana

New Castle, IN
5
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Free assessment
  • Pros icon Good Customer Service
  • Pros icon Educational Website

Services Offered

  • Service icon Screen Repair
  • Service icon Custom Window Designs
  • Service icon Glass Doors
  • Service icon Window Replacement/Installation

Website: https://www.screenmobile.com/east-central-indiana/
Address: 4688 E County Rd 200 N, New Castle, IN 47362
Phone: (765) 524-1848

Budget Blinds of Muncie and Noblesville

Muncie, IN
4.9
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Educational Website
  • Pros icon Free assessment
  • Pros icon Timely Service
  • Pros icon Good Customer Service

Services Offered

  • Service icon Energy-Efficient Options
  • Service icon Window Replacement/Installation
  • Service icon Custom Window Designs

Website: https://budgetblinds.com/Muncie_IN/
Address: 827 S Tillotson Ave, Muncie, IN 47304
Phone: (765) 759-0521

True Crew Windows and Doors

Muncie, IN
4.9
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Educational Website
  • Pros icon Price Transparency
  • Pros icon Free assessment

Services Offered

  • Service icon Energy-Efficient Options
  • Service icon Window Replacement/Installation
  • Service icon Custom Window Designs
  • Service icon Glass Doors

Website: https://truecrewwindows.com/
Address: 1112 W Centennial Ave, Muncie, IN 47303
Phone: (765) 273-7191

Surber's Windows and Doors

Anderson, IN
4.9
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Timely Service
  • Pros icon Good Customer Service
  • Pros icon Price Transparency
  • Pros icon Free assessment

Services Offered

  • Service icon Energy-Efficient Options
  • Service icon Double-Hung
  • Service icon Vinyl Frames
  • Service icon Glass Showers
  • Service icon Window Replacement/Installation
  • Service icon Glass Doors

Website: https://www.surbersusa.com/
Address: 2323 Raible Ave, Anderson, IN 46011
Phone: (765) 642-0851

L.J. Stone, Inc. - Baths, Showers, Windows, Doors and Patio Covers

Muncie, IN
4.9
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Price Transparency
  • Pros icon Free assessment
  • Pros icon Good Customer Service
  • Pros icon Educational Website
  • Pros icon Timely Service

Services Offered

  • Service icon Glass Doors
  • Service icon Window Replacement/Installation
  • Service icon Bay Windows
  • Service icon Double-Hung
  • Service icon Glass Showers

Website: http://www.ljstone.com/
Address: 9100 Wheeling Ave, Muncie, IN 47304
Phone: (877) 544-2957

Crystal Glass Inc

Muncie, IN
3.1
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Free assessment
  • Pros icon Good Customer Service
  • Pros icon Price Transparency
  • Pros icon Educational Website

Services Offered

  • Service icon Storm/Impact Windows
  • Service icon Glass Repair
  • Service icon Mirrors
  • Service icon Window Replacement/Installation
  • Service icon Energy-Efficient Options
  • Service icon Glass Showers
  • Service icon Screen Repair

Website: http://www.crystalglassmuncie.com/
Address: 3925 W Kilgore Ave, Muncie, IN 47304
Phone: (765) 284-3341

Connersville Mirror & Glass Works Inc

Connersville, IN
3.8
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Price Transparency
  • Pros icon Educational Website
  • Pros icon Free assessment
  • Pros icon Good Customer Service

Services Offered

  • Service icon Glass Showers
  • Service icon Window Replacement/Installation
  • Service icon Mirrors

Website: http://mirrorglassworks.com/
Address: 319 E 9th St, Connersville, IN 47331
Phone: (765) 825-1281

Fadely Home Design

Fishers, IN
4.9
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Price Transparency
  • Pros icon Free assessment
  • Pros icon Good Customer Service
  • Pros icon Educational Website

Services Offered

  • Service icon Window Replacement/Installation
  • Service icon Vinyl Frames

Website: http://www.fadelyhomedesign.com/
Address: 10627 Thorny Rdg Trce, Fishers, IN 46037
Phone: (317) 594-8693

Shorts Glass and Plastic, llc- Glass Replacement, Repair Muncie Indiana

Muncie, IN
3.0
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Free assessment
  • Pros icon Good Customer Service
  • Pros icon Educational Website
  • Pros icon Timely Service
  • Pros icon Price Transparency

Services Offered

  • Service icon Glass Repair
  • Service icon Window Repair
  • Service icon Mirrors
  • Service icon Window Replacement/Installation
  • Service icon Glass Doors
  • Service icon Glass Showers

Website: https://shortsglassandplastic.com/
Address: 2803 N Walnut St, Muncie, IN 47303
Phone: (765) 289-5858

Overhead Door Co. of Indianapolis

Indianapolis, IN
4.8
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Free assessment
  • Pros icon Price Transparency
  • Pros icon Educational Website
  • Pros icon Good Customer Service

Services Offered

  • Service icon Vinyl Frames
  • Service icon Energy-Efficient Options
  • Service icon Window Replacement/Installation
  • Service icon Double-Hung
  • Service icon Glass Doors
  • Service icon Window Repair
  • Service icon Bay Windows

Website: http://www.myohd.com/
Address: 8811 Bash St, Indianapolis, IN 46256
Phone: (317) 981-7446

The Glass Guru

Fishers, IN
4.8
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Price Transparency
  • Pros icon Timely Service
  • Pros icon Good Customer Service
  • Pros icon Free assessment
  • Pros icon Educational Website

Services Offered

  • Service icon Triple Pane Glass
  • Service icon Storm/Impact Windows
  • Service icon Glass Repair
  • Service icon Wood Frames
  • Service icon Mirrors
  • Service icon Fiberglass Frames
  • Service icon Screen Repair
  • Service icon Window Replacement/Installation
  • Service icon Custom Glass
  • Service icon Vinyl Frames
  • Service icon Skylights
  • Service icon Glass Showers
  • Service icon Energy-Efficient Options
  • Service icon Tempered Glass
  • Service icon Window Repair
  • Service icon Metal Frames
  • Service icon Glass Doors

Website: https://www.theglassguru.com/indy-north-in/
Address: 10089 Allisonville Rd # c, Fishers, IN 46038
Phone: (317) 286-6079

Glass Doctor of Indianapolis

Indianapolis, IN
4.6
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Educational Website
  • Pros icon Price Transparency
  • Pros icon Good Customer Service

Services Offered

  • Service icon Mirrors
  • Service icon Custom Glass
  • Service icon Glass Repair
  • Service icon Window Replacement/Installation
  • Service icon Window Repair
  • Service icon Energy-Efficient Options
  • Service icon Glass Showers

Website: https://glassdoctor.com/indianapolis
Address: 7753 89th St, Indianapolis, IN 46256
Phone: (317) 577-5415

Window Consultants of Indiana

Carmel, IN
4.9
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Timely Service
  • Pros icon Free assessment
  • Pros icon Educational Website
  • Pros icon Price Transparency

Services Offered

  • Service icon Energy-Efficient Options
  • Service icon Wood Frames
  • Service icon Window Repair
  • Service icon Window Replacement/Installation
  • Service icon Storm/Impact Windows

Website: https://wci-4u.com/
Address: 974 3rd Ave SW, Carmel, IN 46032
Phone: (317) 939-1700

Northside Glass & Mirror

Indianapolis, IN
4.8
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Timely Service
  • Pros icon Price Transparency
  • Pros icon Educational Website
  • Pros icon Good Customer Service
  • Pros icon Free assessment

Services Offered

  • Service icon Glass Showers
  • Service icon Window Replacement/Installation
  • Service icon Custom Glass
  • Service icon Mirrors

Website: https://www.northsideglass.com/
Address: 7206 N Keystone Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46240
Phone: (317) 251-8244

Hometown Window and Door Company LLC

Carmel, IN
4.7
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Good Customer Service
  • Pros icon Free assessment
  • Pros icon Educational Website
  • Pros icon Price Transparency

Services Offered

  • Service icon Glass Doors
  • Service icon Bay Windows
  • Service icon Window Replacement/Installation

Website: http://www.hometownwindowteam.com/
Address: 240 W Carmel Dr, Carmel, IN 46032
Phone: (317) 688-8100

Pella Windows & Doors of Indianapolis

Indianapolis, IN
4.4
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Price Transparency
  • Pros icon Good Customer Service
  • Pros icon Free assessment
  • Pros icon Educational Website

Services Offered

  • Service icon Glass Doors
  • Service icon Double-Hung
  • Service icon Window Replacement/Installation

Website: https://www.pellabranch.com/indianapolis/showrooms/indianapolis/
Address: 4705 E 96th St, Indianapolis, IN 46240
Phone: (317) 981-3720

Outer Limits Construction Co

Greenwood, IN
5.0
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Price Transparency
  • Pros icon Timely Service

Services Offered

  • Service icon Window Replacement/Installation

Website: http://www.outerlimitsconstruction.com/
Address: 49 N Emerson Ave, Greenwood, IN 46143
Phone: (317) 281-4651
New Castle Window Cost Calculator

Calculate how much you can expect to pay for window installation and replacement in New Castle, IN using our customized window cost calculator.

Estimated Window Cost:
161 homeowners have requested a free estimate in the last 3 days.

Estimates will vary based on window dimensions and other unique factors to your home. Getting in touch with a local window installer is the best way to get an accurate cost estimate for your home.

How Installing Energy-Efficient Windows in New Castle Saves You Money

By upgrading to energy-efficient windows, you and your family can enjoy several benefits, including:

  • Protect your investment: If you have a relatively old home, your windows are most likely in need of replacement. Updating your windows can improve the insulation in your home and also help increase the value of your property if you decide to sell.
  • Protect your valuables: The low-emissivity coatings on many Energy Star certified windows help reduce damage from the sun's UV rays to your floors, carpets and furniture.
  • Reduce your carbon footprint: Since energy-efficient windows improve the insulation in your home, you can lower your carbon footprint by about 12%, according to Energy Star.
  • Save on electricity bills: The Department of Energy estimates that heat gained or lost through windows makes up around 25-30% of household energy use. Upgrading to energy-efficient windows can help lower that number, which helps you save $362 a year on your bills.

Estimated Cost of Window Replacement in New Castle

Let’s take a look at the cost of window replacement and the kinds of services you may need for your home.

How Much Do New Windows Cost?

The typical cost to replace one window is about $600 but can range anywhere from $200 to $1,200. These numbers vary based on the specifics of your installation, including material, size, number of windows, type, the location of your home and more.

It’s also worth keeping in mind that energy-efficient windows will cost more upfront, but Energy Star estimates that upgrading the windows on your New Castle home translates to an average energy savings of $236 to $319 each year for single-pane window replacement, or between $87 to $126 each year for double-pane windows. The amount of money you’ll save by upgrading to energy-efficient windows varies based on your local climate, energy rates and other factors unique to your home.

How much your window installation costs will also vary based on the kind of window material you choose for the frames. Wood windows are usually the most expensive, although it depends on whether they are 100% wood or clad with aluminum or vinyl. Fiberglass windows also tend to be a bit more expensive than vinyl, but they are shown to be more efficient.

What Services do Window Installers Offer?

The first step when planning a replacement is to figure out whether you want a full-frame or pocket installation.

A full-frame installation is a total window replacement. It involves removing the old window, the windowsill, and the exterior and interior trim. It also involves extra materials, including insulation and drip edges, which raise the overall cost of the project. It’s also worth noting that it’s not uncommon for homeowners to have to touch up the paint surrounding the window after a full-frame installation. Pocket installations are on the simpler end and won’t carry as large a bill, as they involve merely replacing the window within its existing frame. But if the frame has any damage, you should opt for a full-frame installation instead.

Your window replacement company will be able to help you decide what’s best for your needs. In New Castle, the decision will mostly depend on how old your home is and if there’s any moisture damage. Wood can decay if not properly maintained over the years, so it’s good to have a professional assess your frames and window sills.

Best Availability

Renewal by Andersen

★★★★★
4.5
  • Great industry reputation
  • Member of US Green Building Council
  • Manufactures products in-house
Buy One Window, Get One 40% OFF
Get Estimate

Best Energy-Efficient Features

Champion

★★★★★
4.5
  • Many years of experience
  • Low prices relative to competitors
  • Limetime warranty
Buy 2 Windows, Get 2 Free
Get Estimate

Power Home

★★★★★
4.5
  • Uses eco-friendly materials
  • Well-trained, certified installers
  • Lifetime or lengthy warranty
Next-Day Appointments Available
Get Estimate

How We Choose the Best Window Installers in New Castle

In our search to make your home improvements easier and more eco-friendly in New Castle, the EcoWatch team landed on the above companies as the top window installation companies in the city. Along with energy efficiency, we assessed each installer and assigned rankings using the following methodology:

Service Area

This one is pretty self-explanatory, but we’ve chosen to highlight window installation companies that serve the New Castle area so you can find the right window installation company near you.

Work Quality

We’re willing to bet that you’re looking for professionals who do a great job installing windows. We’ve vetted each company included in our guide to ensure its technicians are well-qualified and that the company has gotten a lot of positive customer feedback to vouch for its service.

Customer Reviews

Customer feedback is another very important review factor. If the majority of customers don’t have positive things to say about their service from a certain window installation company, you won’t see it featured on EcoWatch.

Cost

Cheaper windows certainly don’t mean better windows, but we know many of our readers would like to keep costs low when possible. When analyzing the prices of providers, we awarded higher points to companies with reasonable prices and accessible financing rather than “cheaper” services.

Warranty

Protecting your investment in new windows is important to many homeowners. That’s why window installation companies that give you lengthy warranties for products, parts and labor rank higher with EcoWatch.

Years of Experience

Due to New Castle’s climate, homeowners need to be wary of low efficiency, rot and water damage. We factored in local experience to reflect the ability of New Castle window companies to prepare homes for these issues. If a company has less than 10 years of experience, it loses points in this category.

New Castle, IN Window Replacement FAQs

What is the average cost to install new windows in a home?

The national average cost of installing a single window is about $600 but can range between $200 and $1,200, depending on several factors. The price is typically dependent on the type and material of the window, the location of your property and the size of the window. Also, remember that energy-efficient windows may cost more upfront but can save you a decent amount of money a year in energy bills.

What are the most common kinds of replacement windows?

The most common kinds of windows for homes are awning windows, double-hung and single-hung windows, transom windows, casement windows, bay windows, picture windows and slider windows.

What services do window installation companies offer?

Window installation companies will do the entire process — from replacing old windows with brand-new ones to cleaning up after the installation. In addition, some companies offer window manufacturing, customization and repairs.

Should I replace all my windows at the same time?

If you’re upgrading your windows to save on your energy bills, replacing all of the windows at the same time is the only way to see a noticeable difference. On the other hand, if you have only a few windows that are broken or drafty, you can replace just those.

How long does it usually take to install windows?

Each window takes about 30 minutes to install based on the kind of window. However, the window installation can take two days or more if you need to have a lot of windows installed.