18 Best Window Replacement Companies in New Castle, IN (Mar 2023)
Window Companies Near Me

If you're thinking about upgrading to new windows, our guide to the best window installation companies can help.

We analyzed all the top window installers in New Castle and selected the top 18 based on:

  • Customer reviews
  • Window replacement expertise
  • Popularity with home-owners like you
EcoWatch Local Advisors

By EcoWatch Local Advisors

Updated March 14, 2023

Why you can trust EcoWatch

Our panel of energy experts work tirelessly to create unbiased reviews and informative content to help homeowners make educated decisions. No other windows site has covered energy efficiency and sustainability as long as EcoWatch, which means we're going to help you find windows replacements that will save on your energy bill and put more money back in your wallet.

A guide on the top window installation companies in New Castle may not seem like the most captivating article on EcoWatch, but trust us, windows have more of an impact on your life than you might think. Drafty windows can make your AC or heater work extra hard in the summer or winter.

Installing energy-efficient windows on your home can help you save money every month on your electricity bills — and you can help the environment as well.

As windows are so important for your home, picking the right company for you is a big decision to make. That's why the EcoWatch team has curated this list of the top window replacement companies, so you can make an informed decision more easily.

Best Overall

Renewal by Andersen

★★★★★
4.5

  • Manufactures products in-house
  • Great industry reputation
  • Award-winning company
  • More expensive than competition

Best Affordability

Window World

★★★★★
4.5

  • Lifetime warranty
  • Large serice area
  • Great industry reputation
  • Quality of service will depend on your area

Best for Residential Windows

Window Nation

★★★★★
4

  • Custom designs
  • Manufactures products in-house
  • Wide variety of products and services
  • Installation not covered by warranty

Best Window Replacement Companies in New Castle

The EcoWatch team assessed dozens of installers that serve the New Castle area to find the top window installation companies by our standards. The companies we've reviewed in this article scored best in our categories: energy-efficient offerings, customer service, availability, price and more.

Renewal by Andersen logo
FAST QUOTE
as little as 30 seconds
Best Overall

Renewal by Andersen

★★★★★
BBB Rating: A
Locations: Nationwide
Founded: 1995
Pros:
  • Pros icon Manufactures products in-house
  • Pros icon Great industry reputation
  • Pros icon Award-winning company
Cons:
  • Pros icon More expensive than competition

Renewal by Andersen provides the best availability in New Castle. Andersen has over 27 years of experience in the industry, and it currently serves nearly every state except Mississippi and West Virginia.

You may want to consider going with Andersen if you're looking for a installer that uses in-home estimates and advanced digital tools to help you plan and visualize your project before getting started.

Energy Efficiency of Renewal by Andersen Windows

Renewal by Andersen offers some Energy Star windows, but note that not all its windows are energy-efficient, so be sure to mention that you want high-quality Energy Star windows when inquiring. A handful of windows manufactured by the Andersen corporation were awarded Energy Star’s “Most Efficient” in 2021, and Andersen was named Energy Star’s Partner of the Year in 2019.

How much does Renewal by Andersen cost in New Castle?

Though pricing information is not available on Andersen's website, based on customer feedback, you can expect to pay anywhere between $750 to $1,250 per window for an installation with Andersen. You can request a free quote on its website for more information about the cost.

Window World logo
FAST QUOTE
as little as 30 seconds
Best Affordability

Window World

★★★★★
BBB Rating: A+
Locations: Nationwide
Founded: 1995
Pros:
  • Pros icon Lifetime warranty
  • Pros icon Large serice area
  • Pros icon Great industry reputation
Cons:
  • Pros icon Quality of service will depend on your area

Window World has windows expertise in New Castle. It's the largest window replacement company in the country, known for its vinyl windows and affordability. Window World has around 27 years of experience in the window replacement business. Many positive reviews from customers online back the provider's reputation.

If you're looking for a company that is certified by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and Energy Star and supports charities like St. Jude Children’s Research Hospital, Window World may be the company for you.

Energy Efficiency of Window World Windows

Window World offers some Energy Star windows, but note that not all its windows are energy-efficient, so make sure you ask for high-quality Energy Star windows when inquiring. Its high-performance Low-E (low-emissivity) coatings and argon gas insulation offer exceptional efficiency and performance for any home.

How much does Window World cost in New Castle?

Window World doesn't have any cost information listed on its website, but it's known for offering some of the most affordable window installations around. If you'd like more accurate information, you can get a quote on the company's website.

Window Nation logo
FAST QUOTE
as little as 30 seconds
Best for Residential Windows

Window Nation

★★★★★
BBB Rating: A
Locations: Regional
Founded: 2006
Pros:
  • Pros icon Custom designs
  • Pros icon Manufactures products in-house
  • Pros icon Wide variety of products and services
Cons:
  • Pros icon Installation not covered by warranty

Window Nation offers the best residential windows in New Castle. It's a company that serves hundreds of thousands of homeowners, mostly in the mid-Atlantic region of the U.S. This company has been in business since 2006 and currently serves residents within 75 miles of its showrooms, which are in 13 states. The company has hundreds of positive reviews from customers on online review websites.

It has established itself as a company that gives customers the opportunity to view products and to speak to a representative in person in its showrooms.

Energy Efficiency of Window Nation Windows

Window Nation's commitment to sustainability shows in its energy-efficient window offerings. Each product has windowpanes coated with a Low-E (low emissivity) glaze that prevents damaging UV rays from heating your home. Plus, the spaces between double- and triple-pane windows are filled with argon gas that’s been proven to improve home insulation.

How much does Window Nation cost in New Castle?

Prices aren't mentioned on Window Nation's website, but based on customer feedback, you can expect to pay between $300 and $525 per window installed, making it a more affordable option compared to competitors. The best way to know for sure is to get a free quote from the company.

Universal Windows Direct logo
FAST QUOTE
as little as 30 seconds
Best Warranty

Universal Windows Direct

★★★★★
BBB Rating: A
Locations: Nationwide
Founded: 2002
Pros:
  • Pros icon Makes charitable contributions
  • Pros icon Manufactures products in-house
  • Pros icon Wide variety of products and services
  • Pros icon Lifetime warranty
Cons:
  • Pros icon Limited service area
  • Pros icon Some installations carried out by third-party contractors
  • Pros icon Quality of service will depend on your area

Universal Windows Direct is a company that has grown immensely since its inception in 2002, and now has several franchise dealers nationwide. This company has been operating since 2002 and currently provides services to 27 states nationwide. Its reputation is backed by several positive reviews on customer review websites.

Universal may be the company for you if you want one that has an industry-leading warranty covering products, parts and workmanship for life.

Energy Efficiency of Universal Windows Direct Windows

Universal Windows Direct carries some Energy Star windows, but note that not all its windows are energy-efficient, so be sure to ask for Energy Star windows when inquiring. The company offers energy-efficient UniShield brand windows. According to its website, UniShield window packages have higher gas fill rates and longer gas retention than most other brands on the market, and they are Energy Star products.

How much does Universal Windows Direct cost in New Castle?

Though prices are not available on Universal's website, installations typically range from $225 to $425 per window based on customer feedback. That makes Universal Windows Direct more of a budget-friendly option for window repair and replacements. If you'd like more accurate pricing information, you can get a quote on the company's website.

We've recommended companies with good reputations, but bear in mind that some national companies have independently owned locations in New Castle, so the quality of service may vary depending on your local crew. We have tried to be unbiased and transparent by including pros and cons for each company reviewed.

More Window Replacement Companies in New Castle

Clemens Home Solutions

Muncie, IN
4.3
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Arrives on Time
  • Pros icon Educational Website
  • Pros icon Locally Recognized for Quality
  • Pros icon Free Quotes

Services Offered

  • Service icon Residential Windows
  • Service icon Energy-Efficient Options
  • Service icon Custom Window Designs
  • Service icon Aluminum Window Frames
  • Service icon Double-Hung
  • Service icon Sliding Glass

Website: http://clemenshomesolutions.com/
Address: 2222 S Madison St, Muncie, IN 47302
Phone: (765) 741-8214

We Do Windows, LLC

Fishers, IN
3.3
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Excellent Customer Service
  • Pros icon Educational Website
  • Pros icon Reliable Appointment Windows
  • Pros icon No-fee Quotes

Services Offered

  • Service icon Custom Windows
  • Service icon Residential Windows
  • Service icon Business Windows

Website: http://www.wedowindowsllc.com/
Address: 11650 Olio Rd Suite 1000, Fishers, IN 46037
Phone: (317) 362-2447

Custom Exteriors

Greenfield, IN
3.3
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Excellent Customer Service
  • Pros icon Reliable Appointment Windows
  • Pros icon Locally Recognized for Quality
  • Pros icon Price Transparency

Services Offered

  • Service icon Custom Windows
  • Service icon Fast Delivery
  • Service icon Double-Hung

Website: https://www.customexteriors.com/
Address: 1739 N 600 W, Greenfield, IN 46140
Phone: (317) 894-0152

Connersville Mirror & Glass Works Inc

Connersville, IN
3.1
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Free Quotes
  • Pros icon Excellent Customer Service
  • Pros icon No-Hassle Pricing
  • Pros icon Educational Website

Services Offered

  • Service icon Glass Showers
  • Service icon Residential Windows
  • Service icon Custom Windows
  • Service icon Commercial Windows
  • Service icon Sliding Glass

Website: http://mirrorglassworks.com/
Address: 319 E 9th St, Connersville, IN 47331
Phone: (765) 825-1281

L.J. Stone Company

Muncie, IN
3.0
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Price Transparency
  • Pros icon Free Quotes
  • Pros icon Good Customer Service
  • Pros icon Award-Winning

Services Offered

  • Service icon Custom Window Designs
  • Service icon Energy-Efficient Options
  • Service icon Double-Hung

Website: http://www.ljstone.com/
Address: 9100 Wheeling Ave, Muncie, IN 47304
Phone: (877) 544-2957

Jet Window Cleaning and Home Services

Noblesville, IN
2.9
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Dependable Service
  • Pros icon No-fee Quotes
  • Pros icon Helps Educate Customers
  • Pros icon Excellent Customer Service

Services Offered

  • Service icon Custom Window Designs

Website: https://jetwindowcleaningandhomeservices.com/
Address: 14350 Mundy Dr Ste 800, Noblesville, IN 46060
Phone: (317) 428-9444

Crystal Glass Inc

Muncie, IN
2.9
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Helps Educate Customers
  • Pros icon No-Hassle Pricing
  • Pros icon Good Customer Service
  • Pros icon No-fee Quotes

Services Offered

  • Service icon Custom Windows
  • Service icon Residential Windows
  • Service icon Commercial Windows
  • Service icon Sliding Glass

Website: http://www.crystalglassmuncie.com/
Address: 3925 W Kilgore Ave, Muncie, IN 47304
Phone: (765) 284-3341

Modern Builders Supply, Inc. Muncie Branch

Muncie, IN
2.9
★★★★★
  • Pros icon No-Hassle Pricing
  • Pros icon Helps Educate Customers
  • Pros icon Reliable Service
  • Pros icon Good Customer Service

Services Offered

  • Service icon Custom Windows
  • Service icon Residential Windows
  • Service icon Aluminum Window Frames
  • Service icon Commercial Windows

Website: https://modernbuilderssupply.com/branches/in/muncie.html
Address: 3111 E Jackson St, Muncie, IN 47303
Phone: (765) 288-4758

Window World of Muncie

Muncie, IN
2.9
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Helps Educate Customers
  • Pros icon Price Transparency
  • Pros icon No-fee Quotes
  • Pros icon Good Customer Service

Services Offered

  • Service icon Custom Windows
  • Service icon Residential Windows
  • Service icon Sliding Glass
  • Service icon Double-Hung

Website: https://www.windowworldmuncie.com/
Address: 3508 Wheeling Ave, Muncie, IN 47304
Phone: (765) 281-0008

Pella Windows & Doors of Muncie

Muncie, IN
2.9
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Educational Website
  • Pros icon No-Hassle Pricing
  • Pros icon Free Quotes
  • Pros icon Good Customer Service

Services Offered

  • Service icon Custom Windows
  • Service icon Sliding Glass
  • Service icon Commercial Windows
  • Service icon Double-Hung

Website: https://www.pellabranch.com/indianapolis/showrooms/muncie/
Address: 3309 N Everbrook Ln, Muncie, IN 47304
Phone: (765) 286-7106

Taylor Home Improvement

Noblesville, IN
2.9
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Free Quotes
  • Pros icon Price Transparency
  • Pros icon Excellent Customer Service
  • Pros icon Locally Recognized for Quality

Services Offered

  • Service icon Custom Window Designs
  • Service icon Residential Windows
  • Service icon Energy-Efficient Options
  • Service icon Commercial Windows

Website: https://www.taylorhomeimprovement.net/
Address: 11790 IN-32, Noblesville, IN 46060
Phone: (317) 523-7186

Greenfield Glass & Mirror

Greenfield, IN
2.9
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Excellent Customer Service
  • Pros icon No-Hassle Pricing
  • Pros icon Educational Website
  • Pros icon No-fee Quotes

Services Offered

  • Service icon Custom Windows
  • Service icon Residential Windows
  • Service icon Commercial Windows
  • Service icon Double-Hung

Website: http://www.greenfieldglassandmirror.com/
Address: 1228 E Main St, Greenfield, IN 46140
Phone: (317) 467-4268

Anderson Home Improvement LLC

Richmond, IN
2.9
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Good Customer Service
  • Pros icon Locally Recognized for Quality
  • Pros icon Price Transparency
  • Pros icon No-fee Quotes

Services Offered

  • Service icon Custom Window Designs
  • Service icon Residential Windows
  • Service icon Business Windows
  • Service icon Sliding Glass

Website: http://www.andersonhomeimprovements.biz/
Address: 4332 US-27 S, Richmond, IN 47374
Phone: (765) 966-5423

Surber's Windows and Doors

Anderson, IN
2.7
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Free Quotes
  • Pros icon Price Transparency
  • Pros icon Good Customer Service
  • Pros icon Reliable Service

Services Offered

  • Service icon Custom Window Designs
  • Service icon Glass Showers
  • Service icon Sliding Glass

Website: https://www.surbersusa.com/
Address: 2323 Raible Ave, Anderson, IN 46011
Phone: (765) 642-0851

Fadely Home Design

Fishers, IN
2.6
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Excellent Customer Service
  • Pros icon Free Quotes
  • Pros icon Locally Recognized for Quality
  • Pros icon Helps Educate Customers

Services Offered

  • Service icon Custom Windows

Website: http://www.fadelyhomedesign.com/
Address: 10627 Thorny Rdg Trce, Fishers, IN 46037
Phone: (317) 594-8693

True Crew Windows and Doors

Muncie, IN
2.4
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Helps Educate Customers
  • Pros icon Free Quotes
  • Pros icon Excellent Customer Service
  • Pros icon No-Hassle Pricing

Services Offered

  • Service icon Custom Window Designs
  • Service icon Sliding Glass

Website: http://www.truecrewwindows.com/
Address: 1112 W Centennial Ave, Muncie, IN 47303
Phone: (765) 273-7191

Scott Door Service Inc

Richmond, IN
2.3
★★★★★
  • Pros icon No-Hassle Pricing
  • Pros icon Good Customer Service
  • Pros icon Free Quotes

Services Offered

  • Service icon Custom Windows
  • Service icon Commercial Windows
  • Service icon Sliding Glass

Website: http://www.scottdoor.com/
Address: 3162 IN-38, Richmond, IN 47374
Phone: (765) 966-2603

Neal's Custom Exterior

IN-3, IN
2.0
★★★★★
  • Pros icon Free Quotes
  • Pros icon Price Transparency

Services Offered

  • Service icon Custom Windows
  • Service icon Residential Windows
  • Service icon Business Windows

Website: http://www.nealscustomexterior.com/
Address: 9216 2224, IN-3, New Castle, IN 47362
Phone: (765) 529-6087

How Installing Energy-Efficient Windows in New Castle Saves You Money

When you upgrade to energy-efficient windows, you may see several perks, including:

  • Save on energy bills: Because energy-efficient windows reduce the amount of energy needed to heat or cool your home, the switch can help you save about $362 annually on your energy bills in New Castle.
  • Protect your investment: When you have an older home, your windows could also be outdated or drafty. Keeping your windows up to date is an important part of maintaining your property and its value.
  • Decrease your carbon footprint: In New Castle, you can reduce your indirect greenhouse gas emissions by about 622 pounds per year after you upgrade to energy-efficient windows.
  • Protect your valuables from fading: The low-emissivity coatings on many energy-efficient windows filter out harmful UV rays, preventing fading of your furniture, carpet and other valuables.

Estimated Cost of Window Replacement in New Castle

When looking into window installation, each company offers varying services and prices. Let's go over some average costs and services.

How Much Do New Windows Cost?

On average, homeowners in New Castle can expect that most replacement window installations will range from $250 to $1,200, with the most common installations sitting at around $600. This is because window installations depend on several factors specific to your home, including the size, material and number of windows you need to install, as well as where your property is located.

It's also worth noting that energy-efficient windows will almost always cost more initially, but Energy Star estimates that switching out the windows on your New Castle home translates to an average energy savings of $236 to $319 a year for single-pane window replacement, or between $87 to $126 a year for double-pane windows. How much you'll save by installing energy-efficient windows varies based on your local climate, energy rates and other factors unique to your home.

Costs will also vary based on the material you want for your window frames. Aluminum frames are the least expensive. They're sturdy, light and easy to maintain, but provide poor insulation. Vinyl frames are a bit more expensive and provide good insulation. Composite frames made with wood fibers encased in plastic also provide good insulation and are moderately expensive. Wood frames are the most expensive and are the most in-demand. They're also aesthetically pleasing and provide decent insulation for your home.

What Services do Window Installers Offer?

The first step when considering an installation is to decide whether you want a full-frame or pocket installation.

A full-frame installation is a replacement of the full window. This service involves removing the old window, the windowsill, and the exterior and interior trim. It can also involve extra materials, including insulation and drip edges, which increase the overall cost of the project. It's also worth noting that you may have to touch up the paint around the window after a full-frame installation. Pocket installations are on the simpler end and won't carry as large a bill because they entail merely replacing the window within its existing frame. But if the frame has any damage or rot, you should opt for a full-frame installation instead.

Your window installer can help you decide which type of installation you need.

Best Overall

Renewal by Andersen

★★★★★
4.5

  • Manufactures products in-house
  • Great industry reputation
  • Award-winning company
  • More expensive than competition

Best Affordability

Window World

★★★★★
4.5

  • Lifetime warranty
  • Large serice area
  • Great industry reputation
  • Quality of service will depend on your area

Best for Residential Windows

Window Nation

★★★★★
4

  • Custom designs
  • Manufactures products in-house
  • Wide variety of products and services
  • Installation not covered by warranty

How We Choose the Best Window Installers in New Castle

EcoWatch reviews are different from most reviews, as we examine these companies through a sustainability lens. We have reviewed the top window installers in New Castle mostly based on energy efficiency, as it's the most sustainable option and the best one for homeowners. Energy Star certified windows can reduce your power bills by hundreds of dollars. Along with energy efficiency, our rating methodology is based on the following factors:

Service Area

Because this is a guide for New Castle, we gave more points to companies that cover the city. There are certainly other reputable providers that didn't make the list because of the low odds that they would serve the average homeowner in New Castle.

Work Quality

We're willing to bet that you're looking for a company to do a great job installing windows. We've vetted each installer featured in our guide to make sure its technicians are well-qualified and that the company has received lots of positive customer feedback to vouch for its service.

Customer Reviews

Another self-explanatory yet very important review factor is customer feedback. If the majority of customers don't have positive feedback about their service from a certain company, it won't be featured on EcoWatch.

Cost

This one is a give-and-take: similar to other services, cheap window companies may not provide the highest quality service. Still, we want to make sure we're highlighting companies that provide a wide range of price and financing options so they're accessible to most homeowners.

Warranty

As discussed, windows are a considerable investment, so you'll want to make sure that investment is protected. Window installation companies with lengthy warranties for products, parts and labor rank higher with EcoWatch.

Years of Experience

Due to New Castle's climate, homeowners need to be wary of water damage, low efficiency and rot. We factored in local experience to reflect the ability of New Castle window companies to prepare homes for these issues. If a company has less than 10 years of experience, it loses points in this category.

New Castle, IN Window Replacement FAQs

How much should window installation cost?

The national average cost to replace a window is about $600 but can range between $200 and $1,200, depending on several factors. The price is often influenced by the size of the window, the location of your property and the type and material of the window. Also, remember that energy-efficient windows may cost more initially but can save you a decent amount of money a year in energy bills.

What are the most common types of replacement windows?

The most common kinds of windows for homes are casement windows, transom windows, slider windows, double-hung and single-hung windows, picture windows, awning windows and bay windows.

Can I install my own windows?

If you're handy and have experience with similar home improvement projects, it's possible to install your own windows. But if you don't have the time or experience, we recommend hiring a professional.

When is it time to replace your windows?

Windows have an average lifespan of about 20 to 30 years. If your windows are older than that, they probably need to be replaced. Other than that, if your windows have damage anywhere on them, or they have become difficult to open or close, they may be in need of replacement.

Should I replace all my windows at the same time?

If you want to get more efficient windows and save money on energy costs, replacing all of your windows at once is the only way to see a noticeable difference. However, if you have only a few windows that are damaged or drafty, you can replace just those.

Follow us