4 Best Gutter Guards for Heavy Rain (2023 Guide)
By Dan Simms /
Here’s an overview of our All American gutter guard review:
Each product and or company featured here has been independently selected by the writer. You can learn more about our review methodology here. If you make a purchase using the links included, we may earn commission.
If you’ve been doing research on gutter guard companies you can hire you’ve probably come across All American Gutter Protection — one of the larger gutter guard companies in the country.
Maintaining clean gutters is paramount to ensuring they direct rainwater and snowmelt that runs off of your roof away from your home. Gutters can easily become clogged with leaves, pine needles, acorns, roof grit and other debris, causing poor performance that can lead to structural issues and leaks in your home’s foundation.
Getting high-quality gutter guards and keeping them functioning properly is the best way to prevent these problems from occurring.
In this in-depth guide, we’ll discuss every aspect of All American you need to know about, including the quality of its products, the customer service it provides, how well its gutter guards work and much more.
All American was founded in 2015, so it has around seven years of experience in the gutter guard industry. In that time, it’s maintained overwhelmingly positive customer reviews, as well as a stellar A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau (BBB).
The company is headquartered in North Canton, Ohio, but has numerous branches that serve 13 states across the country. The company is perhaps best known for its customization options, including different colors and sizes to fit most homes and types of gutters.
All American uses durable materials of the highest quality to manufacture its products, including aluminum frames and stainless steel micro mesh — these make up one of the most efficient types of gutter guards. The guards are installed at an angle to match your roof pitch so that water can filter down into your gutters while debris passes over the gutters and drops to the ground.
The materials have outstanding longevity, and they come backed by the company’s lifetime warranty that speaks to the high level of workmanship. The company also guarantees that your gutters won’t clog with its products installed, and it promises to make things right if you run into any issues with the products.
All American uses all recyclable materials, but, unfortunately, this is the company’s only nod to sustainability. There are no other business practices to suggest that the company is green or makes an effort to reduce its contribution to pollution or global warming.
Overall, All American is a great option for gutter covers, but we do wish that it was more environmentally friendly, using recycled and recyclable materials.
+ Overwhelmingly positive customer reviews
+ Lifetime warranty
+ Promise to fix issues with product for as long as you live in your home
+ Recyclable materials
+ High-quality product includes durable aluminum and stainless steel
+ Many customization options
– Not suitable for DIY installation
– Minimal sustainability as a company
The gutter guard industry is rife with companies and products that fail to work as stated and don’t provide customers with the protection they need for their homes. These products are expensive, and we believe you deserve the best equipment possible.
That’s why we’ve assessed All American on several fronts, including its products, warranty and overall value. Below, we’ll discuss the primary factors we used to decide if All American is worthy of your time and money.
All American installs both gutters and gutter guards, but we’ll be discussing the leaf guards only. The frames are made out of aluminum, which is typically considered a better option than the PVC that some other companies use.
Aluminum is resistant to corrosion, so it won’t rust, and it’s durable enough to stand up to serious wear and tear, including extreme weather events like hurricanes, tropical storms and more. All American’s products are suitable for homeowners in extreme climates, and they won’t warp due to changes in temperature and humidity.
The screen on All American’s micro mesh gutter guards is stainless steel, which is the industry standard and highly durable as well. The tiny perforations in the micro mesh allow water to drop through the guard and get routed into your gutters, but they won’t allow tree debris or roof shingle grit into your gutters or downspouts, thereby preventing clogs.
The guards are installed at an angle to allow for optimal performance, and they extend from under your roof shingles to the front edge of the gutter.
All American sets itself apart from its competitors by offering many customization options, including a variety of colors and gutter guards that suit most roof pitches and gutter types. Homeowners looking for unique colors to match their existing gutter systems or to complement their home or roof color will very likely be able to find a suitable product from this company.
The aluminum and stainless steel materials are recyclable, and the guards come backed by the company’s lifetime warranty that promises you’ll experience no clogs for as long as you own your home. If your rain gutters do get clogged, the company will offer to fix the issue at no charge.
The gutter guards themselves work like most other options on the market. The guards extend from under your roof shingles to the front of your gutters.
When rain and debris make their way down your roof, the stainless steel mesh lets water pass through but directs all leaves, sticks, pine needles and other debris over the gutters and down to the ground. The result is perfectly clean gutters and downspouts that never get clogged.
The process for getting All American gutter guards is a simple one as well. First, you contact the company to get a free quote.
Once your property inspection is completed and you approve the estimate, you’ll get an installation date. The third-party installer will come out to install your gutter guards on that date, after which your gutters are guaranteed never to clog as long as you live in your home.
Gutter guards can be expensive, so most homeowners want to know that their investment is protected. All American Gutter Protection offers a lifetime performance warranty, which means you’re guaranteed to have properly functioning gutter guards for life.
The warranty is not transferable, so new homeowners won’t be able to take advantage of it. This is only a minor downside, as most buyers will be pleased enough that you have the guards installed at all.
The warranty offered by All American also states that the company guarantees your gutters will never clog. If they do, All American promises to cover the cost of the necessary gutter cleaning for you.
Keep in mind that the gutter guards themselves can get clogged by very small debris over time, so an annual guard cleaning should be carried out. However, the warranty does guarantee that the gutters and downspouts themselves will remain clog free.
All American is the manufacturer of its gutter guards, but the installation is generally outsourced to third-party companies. These providers are vetted by All American and must be certified before being able to offer the company’s products, but some homeowners are still turned off by the idea of an unrelated company doing the work on their homes.
Based on customer reviews, which we’ll discuss more in-depth further down, most homeowners who choose All American to install their gutter guards are pleased with the quality of customer service they receive and with the apparent communication between All American and the third-party installer.
Some other companies have issues maintaining a positive customer experience when outsourcing work, but All American appears to be doing well with the process.
In most cases, the actual installation takes just a day or two. After the guards are installed, your warranty will be in full effect, and you’ll have a lifetime of peace of mind that you’ll never experience clogged gutters again.
The average cost for gutter guards from All American is around $15-$20 per linear foot. On a standard, 1,000-square foot house, you can expect a price between $3,300 and $4,400.
If you need gutters and gutter guards installed, your price per linear foot could be significantly higher. Compared to other companies in the gutter guard industry, All American is considered around average in terms of pricing.
All American’s service area covers 13 states across the country, including Colorado, Delaware, Florida, Georgia, Kentucky, Indiana, Michigan, New Jersey, North Carolina, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Tennessee and South Carolina.
Its coverage is more comprehensive than that of many of its competitors, and the company is expanding to cover more locations.
Most customer reviews for All American are positive, which is a great sign and somewhat of a rarity in the gutter guard industry. In addition to overwhelmingly positive reviews, the company also maintains accreditation and an A+ rating with the BBB, which is outstanding.
The positive reviews for All American typically include praise for how quickly the gutter guards are installed and how well the products work to keep debris out of the gutters.
Most homeowners are pleased with the professionalism of the sales representatives and the installers, and the majority of customers reviewing this company online also state that follow-ups from sales managers and for warranty purposes are more than adequate. Many customers also comment on the high quality, especially given that the price is lower than what competitors quoted them.
As is the case with any company, there are some negative reviews for All American as well, but most of them have to do with the third-party installer.
Some homeowners have had issues with a lack of professionalism on the part of the installation company, including a lack of safety equipment, a lack of communication with the homeowner and, in some rare cases, damages to landscaping, lighting or garden beds.
Thankfully, most of these issues seem to have been addressed by All American after the fact, but of course, you should still be aware of this possibility before committing to the company.
Most homeowners considering All American will be concerned with the gutter guards’ performance and how the company honors warranty claims. The majority of the reviews posted note that the guards work as intended and that warranty claims are responded to quickly and professionally.
Below, we’ve curated some of the positive and negative reviews for All American to give you an idea of the service and quality you can expect from the company, as well as some of the issues that could arise.
“This gutter is more costly than alternatives, but well worth it. Materials are stainless steel — so no plastic to melt or warp in the hot sun, and nothing to rust. The salesman was thoughtful and not at all pushy. The technician who installed the gutter protection was courteous, and the installation was remarkably quiet and quick. I won’t know until next autumn how well it does with heavy leaf fall, but this product comes with a lifelong warranty, so I am not worried.”
— Rae H. via BBB
“The cost was comparable to other systems. After reading other reviews and speaking with representatives from other suppliers, we picked this one because we thought it was the best available. They removed our old gutters, covered our wood fascia with aluminum, [and] installed new 6″ gutters with gutter guards all in one day. We had no clean-up afterwards. A month later we have no leaves and no water overflowing the gutters.”
— Gary P. via BBB
“We do not recommend AAGP. Salesman gave a convincing presentation so we signed up. Installers were to come between 9-11am. They showed up in a wrecked truck at 12:50pm. They constantly ran a metal saw without eye protection. Installers argued loudly with each other during the entire installation… [I] expressed our dissatisfaction about this job. A manager came out and checked the work; confirmed installation appeared good.”
— Kenneth via BBB
Overall, All American is a great company to choose if you’re looking for gutter or gutter guard installation.
It uses high-quality materials that are durable, provides a lifetime warranty for the leaf guards’ performance and it maintains mostly positive customer reviews and an A+ rating with the BBB, which is outstanding in this industry. The company’s pricing is around average, which is excellent, given the quality and professionalism delivered.
All American routinely ranks in our top five gutter companies overall for these reasons, and while we do wish it took a better stance on being environmentally friendly, the customer satisfaction from All American is high, and most homeowners are pleased with the product they receive.
There are some negative reviews online, but most of them seem to have to do with the third-party installers hired and not with All American directly.
All American is a particularly great option if you’re looking for customization for your gutter guards, including color and size options to fit your home and existing gutters. The company can match most gutter styles and exterior colors, making it one of the best gutter guard companies in the industry for a custom look.
Below, we’ll answer some of the most common questions we get about All American and the products and services offered.
All American typically charges between $15 and $20 per linear foot for gutter guard installation, but the price can vary based on numerous factors. These include your location, the size of your home, the condition of your gutters, whether you need new gutters, the complexity of your roof line and more.
For a 1,000-square foot home, you can expect your total to fall between $3,300 and $4,400. Keep in mind that your cost could be significantly higher if you opt for new gutter installation and gutter guards at the same time.
All American also offers a senior discount to customers 60 and over.
All American gutter guards are not suitable for DIY installation, and they aren’t available for purchase directly either. The company restricts sales of its products through third-party dealers and installers, which means you’ll have to pay for the equipment and the installation together.
This does mean that the cost will be significantly higher than a DIY installation, but most homeowners agree that the price is worth the peace of mind of having a professional install your gutter guards.
Additionally, All American only offers its performance guarantee and lifetime warranty if the products are installed by a professional. That means having a pro complete the work for you is a better option, as it guarantees your gutter guard system works properly.
Finally, the gutter guards from All American get installed under your roof shingles. Done as a DIY home improvement project, this can be dangerous and lead to expensive roof leaks and water damage — not to mention it can void your roof warranty if you have one.
Yes, all gutter guards should be cleaned at least once annually. While All American’s guards are guaranteed to prevent your gutters from getting clogged, the mesh itself can get clogged with small particles and reduce the flow of water into your gutters and downspouts.
By cleaning the gutter protection system once a year, you should be able to avoid any issues that might stem from clogging and debris buildup. In general, homeowners with properly installed gutter guards tend to spend less on gutter cleaning than those without them.
All American doesn’t have a return policy, but it does have a lifetime warranty. There is no policy that lets you get your money back, but the company guarantees your gutters will never clog for as long as you own your home, and it promises to pay for gutter cleaning if they do.
This peace of mind is usually enough to convince homeowners that going with All American for gutter guard installation is a safe option.