Quantcast

First-Ever Climate Oil Index Reveals Worst Fuels for the Planet

Energy

Most people think about oil very generally—it's the fuel that heats homes and powers cars, and most of the changes seen are the yo-yoing prices at the pump. But with ever dwindling supplies and the hunt for crude reaching further corners and deeper pockets of the Earth, oil is changing. What gets pulled out can look anything from a gassy oil to a thick sludge, and can devastate the environment in completely different ways, driving climate change.

This information comes from the first-ever Climate Oil Index released by global think tank Carnegie Endowment for International Peace last week, a stunning analysis of 30 different global oils based on their greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions throughout the entire oil supply chain—oil extraction, crude transport, refining, marketing, product combustion and end use. It's clear, as the energy experts declared, that all oils are not created equal. In fact, according to Carnegie’s analysis, there is more than an 80 percent difference between the lowest and highest GHG emitting oils on the index.

Tengiz of ​Kazakhstan offers the least carbon-intensive petroleum (about 450 kg of carbon per barrel). Canada's Suncor Synthetic produces the most emissions (more than 800 kg of carbon per barrel). Photo Credit: Carnegie Endowment For International Peace

While the appearance of the gasoline that goes into your gas tank hasn't changed much, how it gets there and where it comes from varies widely, such as the thick and dirty muck coming from Canadian tar sands compared to the shale gas coming from hydraulic fracturing. According to the Carnegie analysis, the most GHG-intensive oils identified are gassy oils, heavy oils, watery and depleted oils, and extreme oils:

Gassy oils: Oil fields typically have some natural gas (or methane) and other lighter gases (ethane and others) associated with them. The more gas that is present, the more challenging and costly it is to safely manage these commodities. When the gas associated with certain gassy oils is not handled properly, usually due to lack of appropriate equipment, the gas is burned or released as a waste byproduct. Both flaring and venting operations are damaging to the climate as they release carbon dioxide, methane, and other GHG emissions. Oils that resort to these practices can result in at least 75 percent larger GHG footprints than comparable light oils that do not flare. Flaring policies vary. For example, it has been illegal to flare associated gas in Norway since the 1970s, making these oils some of the lowest emitting oils produced today.

Heavy oils: The heavier the oil, the more heat, steam, and hydrogen required to extract, transport, and transform it into high-value petroleum products like gasoline and diesel. These high-carbon oils also yield higher shares of bottom-of-the-barrel products like petcoke that are often priced to sell. The heaviest oils have total GHG footprints that can be nearly twice as large as lighter oils.

Watery and depleted oils: Depleted oil fields tend to produce significant quantities of water along with the oil. It takes a lot of energy to bring this water to the surface, process it, and reinject or dispose of it. If an oil field has a water-oil ratio of ten to one, that adds nearly 2 tons of water for every barrel of oil produced. Certain depleted oils in California’s San Joaquin Valley, for example, produced 25 or 50 barrels of water per barrel of oil. Oils with high water-oil ratios can have total GHG footprints that are more than 60 percent higher than oils that are not so encumbered.

Extreme oils: Some oils are difficult to access. For example, some oils are buried deeply below the surface, like the Chayvo oil field in Russia’s Sakhalin shelf, which is reached by an incredible set of highly deviated wells that are about 7 miles long. How much energy it takes to recover such resources is highly uncertain. Still other oils are located in areas that sequester greenhouse gases like permafrost, boreal peat bogs, and rainforests. Removing these oils disrupts lands that store significant amounts of carbon, releasing substantial volumes of climate-forcing gases. GHG footprints may be significantly larger for oils that are difficult to access or located in climate-sensitive environments, and this merits further investigation.

"Whether global oil production returns to record levels, wanes or fluctuates in the future, there is little doubt that oils will be increasingly unconventional," the study says. "And there is little doubt that oil extraction, refining, and consumption should be better understood."

The index also revealed that the range of petroleum products produced by refineries, from diesel to asphalt, have varied carbon emissions. In the graph below, you'll see that gasoline releases 370 kilograms of CO2 per barrel compared to petroleum coke (which is similar to coal and is a critical ingredient in the manufacture of aluminum) which emits a whopping 645 kilograms.

CO2 emissions from different applications of petroleum also vary widely. Photo Credit: Carnegie Endowment For International Peace

There are thousands of different types of oils available globally for production and use, but a total of 30 test oils were modeled in the first phase of the index. "The biggest surprise in doing the Oil Climate Index to us was the lack of transparent data," Deborah Gordon, director of the Energy and Climate program at the Carnegie Endowment and one of the study's authors, explained in the video below. "We were very much shocked. There are hundreds, if not thousands of different oils, but there's very limited data, very limited open source data. We found data that we weren't able to use without express permission to use it, which is hard to get." Gordon said in another interview, "Side note, interestingly we don't have any Frack 2S oils. There just wasn't enough data to model those."

With the absence of transparency in Big Oil, one of the goals of the index is to guide investments in oils with the lowest impact first. "There's an abundance of oils in the Earth, and we're going to learn how to pick and choose much more wisely," Gordon said in the video. "That's not only important for the climate, which is what the Oil Climate Index is about, but it's very important to the marketplace because this infrastructure lasts for generations."

"There are many stakeholders when it comes to making oil decisions, so the better information and the more transparent, the easier it will be to make decisions," she said.

YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE

The Real Story Behind the Oil Price Collapse

Fukushima’s 4th Anniversary Brings Hope Amidst Radioactive Ruins as Renewable Energy Revolution Soars

Analysis of California’s Fracking Wastewater Reveals a Slew of Toxic Chemicals Linked to Cancer and Other Illnesses

EcoWatch Daily Newsletter

By George Citroner

The Office of Disease Prevention and Health Promotion and the World Health Organization currently recommend either 150 minutes of moderate intensity exercise (walking, gardening, doing household chores) or 75 minutes of vigorous aerobic exercise (running, cycling, swimming) every week.

But there's little research looking at the benefits, if any, of exercising less than the 75 minute minimum.

Read More Show Less
Mary Daly, president of the San Francisco Federal Reserve Bank, poses for a photograph. Nick Otto / Washington Post / Getty Images

It seems the reality of the climate crisis is too much for the Federal Reserve to ignore anymore.

Read More Show Less
Sponsored

Passengers trying to reach Berlin's Tegel Airport on Sunday were hit with delays after police blocked roads and enacted tighter security controls in response to a climate protest.

Read More Show Less
A military police officer in Charlotte, North Carolina, pets Rosco, a post-traumatic stress disorder companion animal certified to accompany him, on Jan. 11, 2014. North Carolina National Guard

For 21 years, Doug Distaso served his country in the United States Air Force.

He commanded joint aviation, maintenance, and support personnel globally and served as a primary legislative affairs lead for two U.S. Special Operations Command leaders.

But after an Air Force plane accident left him with a traumatic brain injury, post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), and chronic pain, Distaso was placed on more than a dozen prescription medications by doctors at the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs (VA).

Read More Show Less
(L) Selma Three Stone Engagement Ring. (R) The Greener Diamond Farm Project. MiaDonna

By Bailey Hopp

If you had to choose a diamond for your engagement ring from below or above the ground, which would you pick … and why would you pick it? This is the main question consumers are facing when picking out their diamond engagement ring today. With a dramatic increase in demand for conflict-free lab-grown diamonds, the diamond industry is shifting right before our eyes.

Read More Show Less
Sponsored
Preliminary tests of the bubble barrier have shown it to be capable of ushering 80 percent of the canal's plastic waste to its banks. The Great Bubble Barrier / YouTube screenshot

The scourge of plastic waste that washes up on once-pristine beaches and finds its way into the middle of the ocean often starts on land, is dumped in rivers and canals, and gets carried out to sea. At the current rate, marine plastic is predicted to outweigh all the fish in the seas by 2050, according to Silicon Canals.

Read More Show Less
Man stands on stage at Fort Leonard Wood in the U.S. Brett Sayles / Pexels

Wilson "Woody" Powell served in the Air Force during the Korean war. But in the decades since, he's become staunchly anti-war.

Read More Show Less
Sen. Bernie Sanders and Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez at a rally in Council Bluffs, Iowa on Nov. 8. Matt Johnson / CC BY 2.0

By Julia Conley

Joined by Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez Friday night, Sen. Bernie Sanders held the largest rally of any 2020 Democratic presidential candidate to date in Iowa, drawing more than 2,400 people to Iowa Western Community College in Council Bluffs.

Read More Show Less