Quantcast

Environmental Dangers of Fracking Highlighted in Whitepaper

Energy

Virginia Conservation Network

Statement of the Issue

While new technologies in hydraulic fracturing and horizontal drilling are creating a boom in natural gas extraction in the U.S., this type of drilling is not yet underway in western Virginia’s Marcellus or Uttica shale formations. Citizens, conservation organizations and local government officials are concerned about the industry’s potential risks to public health, natural resources and rural lands and the adequacy of current standards. In Virginia, it is important to preserve the zoning authority of local governments to guide the pace, scale and impacts of the industry in their communities.

Background

Gas drilling by high-volume hydraulic fracturing, or hydrofracking, involves injecting water, sand and chemicals at high pressure to break up shale formations and release natural gas. In Virginia, the Marcellus Shale extends under the Allegheny Mountains, on the west side of the Shenandoah Valley, from Frederick County south to Rockbridge. The Marcellus shale formation has been heavily drilled in Pennsylvania and West Virginia over the past eight years, with significant, documented impacts on local communities and the environment.

Environmental and Community Impacts

Hydrofracking requires up to 5 million gallons of water per well and perhaps more. But water in western Virginia is limited, prompting concerns about the adequacy of the region’s supply to accommodate such an intensive industrial use. In addition, sometimes drilling operations withdraw water from small, sensitive streams near wellpads, creating the potential for even more acute local impacts from water withdrawals. Unlike agriculture or domestic water uses, gas drilling does not return fracking fluids to ground or surface supplies without treatment. Roughly one third of the fluid injected into shale gas well returns to the surface as flowback, often mixed with naturally occurring brines and/or radioactive materials. Wastewater must typically be stored on site, and then transported to a wastewater treatment plant or deep underground injection well. In general, local wastewater treatment plants cannot adequately treat the millions of gallons of contaminated wastewater generated by shale gas wells.

Shale gas drilling also poses a risk of groundwater and surface water contamination and air pollution. Marcellus shale drilling has been linked to methane gas pollution in drinking water wells in Pennsylvania. Accidental spills, explosions and improper disposal of shale drilling wastewater have polluted streams and rivers. Also, air quality impacts from pollution leaks during hydrofracking and emissions released during processing and transport can become severe.

Virginia’s Marcellus shale lies beneath drinking water sources for more than 260,000 Shenandoah Valley residents, in and around the George Washington National Forest (GWNF) and the headwaters of the Shenandoah River. In 2010, three Shenandoah Valley counties and two cities asked the U.S. Forest Service to ban or adopt a moratorium on horizontal drilling and/or hydraulic fracturing on the forest to protect water quality, recreation and other resources and prevent the industrialization of public forest lands. The Forest Service studied the issue as part of its GWNF management plan revision and proposed to prohibit horizontal drilling in any future federal oil and gas leases. This proposal has broad local support.

In the Shenandoah Valley, many residents and local elected officials also are deeply concerned about the potential industrialization of rural land, as hydrofracking creates a large industrial footprint. Farms, forests and public lands are transformed by three-to-ten acre well pads, wastewater storage pits, compression tanks and compressor stations, 24-hour industrial lighting, new access roads and pipelines, and often overwhelming traffic from the hundreds of heavy trucks needed to serve each well. These are issues that lie at the heart of each locality’s comprehensive plans and zoning regulations.

The Shenandoah Valley’s local governments and private sector have invested for generations in traditional rural land uses—farming, forestry, tourism and recreation—based on the natural, historic and cultural resources most likely to be harmed by widespread natural gas drilling. Local governments have also invested heavily in comprehensive plans and zoning rules designed to maintain the quality of their communities. The Shenandoah Valley has no history of, or strategy for, economic development based on heavy industrial energy development in its rural areas.

Regulatory Oversight

The boom in shale gas drilling east of the Mississippi provides a clear case of industry getting ahead of regulatory oversight. In 2005, before the impacts of high-volume hydrofracking were better understood and publicized, Congress exempted fracturing from the Safe Water Drinking Act, the Clean Water Act and other major environmental laws. The potential impacts of fracking, particularly on groundwater, are still not fully understood. Several federal studies are currently underway in response to the host of reported environmental and public health problems.

In the absence of sufficient federal oversight, New York, New Jersey and Maryland placed moratoria on hydraulic fracturing until state agencies develop standards specific to shale gas drilling. Pennsylvania and West Virginia, already feeling heavy impacts from the industry, also are working to develop new drilling standards. Those states also suffered from lack of adequate staffing to review permit applications, inspect drilling operations, and conduct enforcement activities. Some of the reported problems have been the result of widespread drilling in remote areas taking place without adequate regulatory supervision.

There are as yet no shale formation gas wells in Virginia, therefore state agencies and local governments lack experience overseeing the use of high-volume hydrofracking in deep, horizontal shale wells. The Virginia Department of Mines, Minerals and Energy (DMME) claims that current state laws and regulations are sufficient, but the rules do not provide comprehensive environmental review nor do they address the full scope of impacts shale gas drilling has on the environment, public health, water quality and local communities. In addition, it is not clear that DMME has adequate staff should a shale drilling boom occur in Virginia. For example, the first shale gas well approved by DMME (but not yet developed) reveals that the current regulations fall short.

DMME granted a permit for a well and associated wastewater holding ponds to be built in a floodplain in the headwaters of the North Fork of the Shenandoah River, upstream of the drinking water intake for the town of Broadway. No emergency management plan will be required, despite the growing number of reports of explosions and other accidents at similar wells in Pennsylvania and West Virginia. Also, there is no formal role for other state agencies, such as the Virginia Department of Game and Insland Fisheries, the Department of Conservation and Recreation, and the Department of Environmental Quality to contribute their expertise to the process.

Recommendations

The heavy footprint of shale gas drilling has the potential to impact local water supply and quality and to compromise traditional rural economic sectors. Local governments have the ability to guide the pace, scale and impacts of hydraulic fracturing in their communities through zoning. Therefore, the zoning authority of local governments over the industry is critical and must be preserved, regardless of any future regulatory action which improves state-level oversight.

States to Virginia’s north and west are reviewing and updating their regulatory structures to better manage the new risks and impacts of high volume hydrofracking. In addition, there are several federal studies underway to better understand the impacts of this new practice. Virginians are fortunate to have the opportunity to apply lessons learned from other studies before undertaking our own prudent updates to Virginia’s Oil and Gas Act.

For more information, click here.

EcoWatch Daily Newsletter

Brazil's right-wing President Jair Bolsonaro is giving President Trump a run for his money in the alternative facts department.

Read More Show Less
Washington Gov. Jay Inslee delivered his 2019 State of the State address on Jan. 15. Governor Jay and First Lady Trudi Inslee / Flickr

Washington Gov. Jay Inslee, who made solving the climate crisis the center of his presidential campaign, is dropping out of the 2020 Democratic primary race.

Read More Show Less
Sponsored
Earthjustice

By Robert Valencia

In April 2018, Afro-Colombian activist Francia Márquez won the prestigious Goldman Environmental Prize, thanks to her work to retake her community's ancestral territories from illegal gold mining. However, her international recognition comes at a very risky price.

Read More Show Less

By Stuart Braun

A year after activist Greta Thunberg first stood in the rain outside the Swedish parliament with her now iconic "Skolstrejk för klimatet" — school strike for the climate — placard, the movement she spawned has set the tone for environmental protest action around the world.

Read More Show Less
Bruno Vincent / Staff / Getty Images

Toy maker Hasbro wants to play in the eco-packaging game. The board game giant will ditch its plastic packaging by 2022. The move means that games like Monopoly, Scrabble and Operation will no longer have shrink wrap, window sheets, plastic bags or elastic bands, as the Associated Press reported.

Read More Show Less
Sponsored
Vaping impaired the circulatory systems of people in a new study. bulentumut / iStock / Getty Images Plus

Vaping one time — even without nicotine — can damage blood vessels, reduce blood flow and create dangerous toxins, according to a new study published in the journal Radiology.

Read More Show Less
A man spreads pesticides on a plantation of vegetables in Rio de Janeiro Brazil. Ze Martinusso / Moment Open / Getty Images

By Jessica Corbett

Pointing to the deaths of more than half a billion bees in Brazil over a period of just four months, beekeepers, experts and activists are raising concerns about the soaring number of new pesticides greenlighted for use by the Brazilian government since far-right President Jair Bolsonaro took office in January — and the threat that it poses to pollinators, people and the planet.

Read More Show Less
SHEALAH CRAIGHEAD

By Elliott Negin

On July 19, President Trump hosted Apollo 11 astronauts Buzz Aldrin and Michael Collins and their families, along with the family of their deceased colleague Neil Armstrong, at a White House event to commemorate the 50th anniversary of the first manned landing on the moon.

Read More Show Less