EcoWatch
Facebook 573k Twitter 238k Instagram 37k Subscribe Subscribe
  • Climate
  • Energy
  • Policy
  • Renewables
  • Culture
  • Science
  • Go Solar Today
      • Top Companies By State
        • California Solar Companies
        • Texas Solar Companies
        • New York Solar Companies
        • Florida Solar Companies
        • See All States
      • Top Incentives By State
        • California Solar Incentives
        • Texas Solar Incentives
        • New York Solar Incentives
        • Florida Solar Incentives
        • See All States
      • Solar Panel Costs By State
        • Solar Panel Costs in California
        • Solar Panel Costs in Texas
        • Solar Panel Costs in New York
        • Solar Panel Costs in Florida
        • See All States
      • Value of Solar by State
        • Is Solar Worth It In California?
        • Is Solar Worth It in Texas?
        • Is Solar Worth It New York?
        • Is Solar Worth It In Florida?
        • See All States
      • Company Reviews
        • Tesla Solar Review
        • Sunrun Solar Review
        • SunPower Solar Review
        • Vivint Solar Review
        • See All Companies
      • Common Solar Questions
        • Can You Get Free Solar Panels?
        • Does Solar Increase Home Value?
        • What’re The Best Solar Batteries?
        • Can You Finance Solar?
        • Where To Buy Solar Panels?
        • Payback On Solar Panels?
      • Solar Resources
        • Interactive Solar Calculator
        • Federal Solar Tax Credit 2023
        • Best Solar Panels For Most Homes
        • Tesla Solar Roof Review
        • Cheapest Solar Panels
      • Companies Compared
        • SunPower vs Tesla Solar
        • SunRun vs Tesla Solar
        • SunRun vs SunPower
        • SunPower vs Momentum Solar
        • SunPower vs ADT Solar
EcoWatch
  • Climate
  • Energy
  • Policy
  • Renewables
  • Culture
  • Science
  • Go Solar Today
    • Go Solar Today
    • Top Companies By State
      • California Solar Companies
      • Texas Solar Companies
      • New York Solar Companies
      • Florida Solar Companies
      • See All States
    • Top Incentives By State
      • California Solar Incentives
      • Texas Solar Incentives
      • New York Solar Incentives
      • Florida Solar Incentives
      • See All States
    • Solar Panel Costs By State
      • Solar Panel Costs in California
      • Solar Panel Costs in Texas
      • Solar Panel Costs in New York
      • Solar Panel Costs in Florida
      • See All States
    • Value of Solar by State
      • Is Solar Worth It In California?
      • Is Solar Worth It in Texas?
      • Is Solar Worth It New York?
      • Is Solar Worth It In Florida?
      • See All States
    • Company Reviews
      • Tesla Solar Review
      • Sunrun Solar Review
      • SunPower Solar Review
      • Vivint Solar Review
      • See All Companies
    • Common Solar Questions
      • Can You Get Free Solar Panels?
      • Does Solar Increase Home Value?
      • What’re The Best Solar Batteries?
      • Can You Finance Solar?
      • Where To Buy Solar Panels?
      • Payback On Solar Panels?
    • Solar Resources
      • Interactive Solar Calculator
      • Federal Solar Tax Credit 2023
      • Best Solar Panels For Most Homes
      • Tesla Solar Roof Review
      • Cheapest Solar Panels
    • Companies Compared
      • SunPower vs Tesla Solar
      • SunRun vs Tesla Solar
      • SunRun vs SunPower
      • SunPower vs Momentum Solar
      • SunPower vs ADT Solar

The best of EcoWatch right in your inbox. Sign up for our email newsletter!

    • About EcoWatch
    • Contact EcoWatch
    • Terms of Use
    • Privacy Policy
    • Learn About Solar Energy
    Facebook 573k Twitter 238k Instagram 37k
    EcoWatch
    • About EcoWatch
    • Contact EcoWatch
    • Terms of Use
    • Privacy Policy
    • Learn About Solar Energy
    Facebook 573k Twitter 238k Instagram 37k
    Home Oceans

    Deep-Sea Mining Could Harm Whales and Dolphins, Too

    By: Olivia Rosane
    Updated: February 21, 2023
    Edited by Chris McDermott
    Facebook icon Twitter icon Pinterest icon Email icon
    The Rainbow Warrior Greenpeace ship bearing witness to deep sea mining in the Pacific Ocean
    The Rainbow Warrior Greenpeace ship bearing witness to deep sea mining in the Pacific Ocean on Aug. 5, 2021. Marten van Dijl / Greenpeace
    Why you can trust us

    Founded in 2005 as an Ohio-based environmental newspaper, EcoWatch is a digital platform dedicated to publishing quality, science-based content on environmental issues, causes, and solutions.

    Facebook icon Twitter icon Pinterest icon Email icon

    Blue whales are the largest animals on Earth, but that didn’t save them when commercial whaling wiped out as much as 97 percent of their numbers. Today, the aquatic giants are still considered Endangered by the International Union for Conservation of Nature Red List, and while their numbers are increasing, they still face threats including vessel strikes and the climate crisis. Now, a new threat may be looming on the horizon: deep-sea mining. 

    Blue whales are one of the 22 to 30 species of cetaceans — the order that includes whales, dolphins and porpoises — that have been documented in the Clarion Clipperton Zone (CCZ), a region in the Pacific Ocean where testing for deep-sea mining has already begun. That’s one of the findings from a Greenpeace Research Laboratories and University of Exeter led study published in Frontiers in Marine Science this month, which researchers believe is the first to look at how deep-sea mining might impact cetaceans. 

    More From EcoWatch
    • Sustainable Home Improvements You Can Make Now
    • How to Lower Your Energy Bill
    • How Do Solar Panels Work?

    “Our primary finding is we don’t know how important these habitats are for these species, we don’t know which species are really using them. And then also, [on] the flip side, we don’t know so much about what the effects of mining might be in future,” study co-author and lecturer in ecology at the University of Exeter Dr. Kirsten Thompson told EcoWatch in an interview. 

    BREAKING: New report from University of Exeter and Greenpeace Research Laboratories confirms that Deep Sea Mining poses a very real threat to whale populations worldwide. 🐋🧵https://t.co/gEqvr4r8Qx

    — Greenpeace USA (@greenpeaceusa) February 16, 2023

    The Precautionary Principle 

    The new paper is the fourth in a series of studies Thompson has helped author that turn a critical look at deep-sea mining, the term for removing mineral deposits from the ocean floor below around 656 feet. The first two, published in 2018, focused on impacts to little understood deep-sea ecosystems and difficulties with governing the process. The third, published in 2021, challenged the notion that mining the seabed is necessary to secure enough of certain types of metals and minerals required for the renewable energy transition. Most of the environmental work on deep-sea mining to date has focused on the “irreversible damage” it could do to vulnerable seafloor ecosystems, but the new paper suggests that larger and more mobile marine animals like whales and dolphins are unlikely to remain unscathed. 

    “Here’s another species group that is facing a huge number of stresses from other human activities and other changes to the oceans and has also, for some species, still not recovered from centuries of exploitation,” Thompson said.

    While marine mammals in general are better studied than deep-sea biodiversity — only around a fifth of marine species have even been described by scientists — those studies typically occur close to shore or to islands. There is much that researchers don’t know about how cetaceans interact with the open ocean areas that would be the focus of mining. The CCZ, for example, is an approximately 11,650,000 square kilometer (4,498,090 square mile) stretch of ocean between Mexico and Hawaii with an average depth of 5,500 meters (approximately 18,045 feet), where 17 exploratory mining licenses have already been granted. Using data from the Ocean Biodiversity Information System-Spatial Ecological Analysis of Megavertebrate Population (OBIS-Seamaps), the researchers were able to map where cetacean sightings overlapped with the CCZ. They found that it provided habitat for several species including blue whales, humpback whales, sperm whales, minke whales, beaked whales, Risso’s dolphins and dwarf and pygmy sperm whales.

    Graphic showing where different whale species interact with the Clarion Clipperton Zone. Thompson et al., 2023 / CC-BY-4.0

    “Although more survey data are needed to determine temporal and spatial use of the CCZ by cetaceans, available data clearly confirm the presence of the aforementioned species in the region,” the study authors wrote. 

    How might deep-sea mining in the CCZ harm the whales and dolphins that pass through?

    “I think primarily something that sticks out is that it’s an industry that’s likely to emit quite a lot of noise, and for certain species that is a real problem,” Thompson said. 

    Mining would likely persist 24-hours a day at frequencies that could make it harder for whales to communicate and therefore lead to changes in their behavior. For example, one study found that existing underwater noise increased the risk that mother humpback whales would become separated from their calves because the human-caused noise would drown out the whales’ calls. 

    While there are many uncertainties about exactly what frequencies deep-sea mining would emit, Thompson argued that decision makers should approach deep-sea mining from the precautionary principle that potential harms should be avoided. 

    ‘It shouldn’t have any commercial reality at all given how little we know,” Thompson said. 

    Ticking Clock

    Thompson’s concern is one shared by many scientists. She is one of 704 marine science and policy experts who has signed a call for a global moratorium on deep-sea mining until its environmental impacts can be truly assessed and understood. Yet the voices urging caution face a ticking clock. In June 2021, Narau triggered something called the “two-year rule.” This meant that the UN’s International Seabed Authority (ISA) — the regulatory body that would handle deep-sea mining — then had two years to set regulations on the practice or it would proceed under existing rules. The deadline comes due on July 9 of this year.

    The ISA will meet further in March and July in Kingston, Jamaica, Greenpeace noted in a press release emailed to EcoWatch. There is some momentum among world leaders to oppose the practice. During the ISA’s last meeting in November of 2022, nations including New Zealand, France, and Chile all urged a halt on deep-sea mining and argued it should not advance in 2023. 

    Tests have been approved, however. Around a month before the cetacean study was published, video footage of a mining trial in the CCZ leaked, showing a vessel owned by Canadian-based The Metals Company releasing wastewater from the seabed out onto the surface of the ocean.

    Thompson noted that the impacts of commercial mining would be of a much greater scale than a test and that the incident exemplified the dangers of approving such a heavy industrial process in the open ocean.

    “What’s also concerning is that these activities are really far offshore, they’re really far away from the scrutiny of the public or any kind of bodies that are able to manage this industry,” she said. “And I think we know from other human activities that when that happens, when things are far off shore, away from public scrutiny, then it’s very, very difficult to manage the impacts of them.” 

    It’s #WorldWhalesDay! Which means it’s perfect timing to sign a petition against deep sea mining and protect them from this new threat >> https://t.co/5PaPzqhOYn pic.twitter.com/ca3bnu5uNY

    — Greenpeace International (@Greenpeace) February 19, 2023

    Whales and Renewables

    The paper comes as whales and renewable energy have been in the news together for a different reason. In January, a group of 12 Jersey Shore mayors wrote a letter to the federal government calling for a moratorium on offshore wind development following a spate of whale strandings along the East Coast, as the Asbury Park Press reported at the time. In this case, however, both conservationists and scientists have argued that there is no evidence that offshore wind farms significantly harm whales and that the letter and similar arguments are a cynical ploy to oppose renewable energy. 

    Deep-sea mining is also argued by some to be necessary for the raw materials needed to expand renewable energy and electric vehicles, yet in this case many environmentalists argue that potential harms outweigh potential benefits. 

    “There has been a lot of talk about wind turbines and whale deaths, but there is no evidence whatsoever connecting the two,” Greenpeace USA’s project lead on deep sea mining Arlo Hemphill said in a press release emailed to EcoWatch. “Meanwhile, the oceans face more threats now than at any time in history. This report makes it clear that if the deep sea mining industry follows through on its plans, the habitats whales rely on will be in even greater danger. Instead of opening up a new industrial frontier in the largest ecosystem on earth, we should be establishing ocean sanctuaries to protect biodiversity.”

    Subscribe to get exclusive updates in our daily newsletter!

      By signing up, you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy & to receive electronic communications from EcoWatch Media Group, which may include marketing promotions, advertisements and sponsored content.

      Olivia Rosane

      Olivia Rosane is a freelance writer and reporter with a decade’s worth of experience. She has been contributing to EcoWatch daily since 2018 and has also covered environmental themes for Treehugger, The Trouble, YES! Magazine and Real Life. She holds a Ph.D. in English Literature from the University of Cambridge and a master’s in Art and Politics from Goldsmiths, University of London.
      Facebook icon Twitter icon Pinterest icon Email icon

      Read More

      Fossil Fuels 101: Everything You Need to Know
      Quick Key Facts
      By Olivia Rosane
      Biden Administration Unveils Nation’s First Ocean Climate Action Plan
      The Biden administration on Tuesday unveiled a new plan to
      By Olivia Rosane
      First-of-its-Kind Study Casts More Shade on Forest Carbon Offsets
      Yet another report has cast doubt on the accuracy and
      By Olivia Rosane

      Subscribe to get exclusive updates in our daily newsletter!

        By signing up, you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy & to receive electronic communications from EcoWatch Media Group, which may include marketing promotions, advertisements and sponsored content.

        Latest Articles

        • Fossil Fuels 101: Everything You Need to Know
          by Olivia Rosane
          March 23, 2023
        • Biden Administration Unveils Nation’s First Ocean Climate Action Plan
          by Olivia Rosane
          March 23, 2023
        • First-of-its-Kind Study Casts More Shade on Forest Carbon Offsets
          by Olivia Rosane
          March 23, 2023
        • Lack of Safe Drinking Water for City Dwellers to Double by 2050: UN Report
          by Cristen Hemingway Jaynes
          March 22, 2023
        • Scientists Develop a Robot to Maintain Plants Grown Under Solar Panels
          by Paige Bennett
          March 22, 2023
        • How to Make Your Own Kombucha
          by Linnea Harris
          March 22, 2023
        • Residents of Louisiana’s ‘Cancer Alley’ Sue Over Environmental Racism
          by Climate Nexus
          March 22, 2023
        • Wetland Methane Emissions Reached ‘Exceptional’ Levels in 2020 and 2021
          by Olivia Rosane
          March 22, 2023
        EcoWatch

        The best of EcoWatch right in your inbox. Sign up for our email newsletter!

          • Climate Climate
          • Animals Animals
          • Health + Wellness Health + Wellness
          • Insights + Opinion Insights + Opinion
          • Adventure Adventure
          • Oceans Oceans
          • Business Business
          • Solar Solar
          • About EcoWatch
          • Contact EcoWatch
          • EcoWatch Reviews
          • Terms of Use
          • Privacy Policy
          • Learn About Solar Energy
          • Learn About Deregulated Energy
          • EcoWatch UK
          Follow Us
          Facebook 573k
          Twitter 238k
          Instagram 37k
          Subscribe Subscribe

          Experts for a healthier planet and life.

          Mentioned by:
          Learn more