Quantcast
Environmental News for a Healthier Planet and Life

Help Support EcoWatch

Court Reaffirms that Gas Company Profits Do Not Trump the Constitutional Rights of Pennsylvania Residents

Energy

Delaware Riverkeeper

A prime example is that Act 13 permits drilling and fracking in all zones, including close to homes in residential zones as seen in this photo.

Opponents of Act 13, an amendment to the Pennsylvania Oil and Gas Act preempting municipal zoning of oil and gas development, won another victory Aug. 15 in Commonwealth Court. The court held oral argument on the question of whether its order declaring Act 13 unconstitutional and unenforceable should be stayed pending the Commonwealth’s appeal to the Pennsylvania Supreme Court. Under Pennsylvania’s appellate court rules, when the Commonwealth appeals from an injunction order, that underlying injunction order is automatically stayed during the course of the appeal.
 
The parties challenging Act 13—including the Delaware Riverkeeper Network and the Delaware Riverkeeper—filed a motion for relief from that automatic stay. In the ruling, the Commonwealth Court agreed that its order enjoining Act 13 should remain in place during the pending appeal. The Court found that the parties challenging Act 13 have a reasonable likelihood of success on appeal, that they would suffer irreparable harm without the injunction blocking enforcement of Act 13, and that there is minimal harm to the public by allowing the injunction to stay in place during the appeal.
 
“This injunction is essential to protect municipalities and the environment from further intrusion that would result if Act 13’s preemption of local zoning was allowed while we are awaiting Supreme Court action.  This rational decision is most welcome as we continue the battle forward to beat back industry interests”, said Delaware Riverkeeper Maya van Rossum.
 
Jordan Yeager, Esq., representing Delaware Riverkeeper Network, Nockamixon Township and Yardley Borough said, “This ruling prevents the chaos that would have ensued if the Corbett administration and gas companies got their way. We are pleased that the Court has once again reaffirmed gas company profits do not trump the constitutional rights of Pennsylvania residents and property owners.”

The legal challenge to the chapter of Act 13 that took over municipal zoning of oil and gas operations was challenged by seven municipalities, Delaware Riverkeeper Network and Dr. Mehernosh Khan in Commonwealth Court challenging Act 13 in March 2012. Act 13 not only amends the Pennsylvania Oil and Gas Act, preempting municipal zoning of oil and gas development, it establishes an impact fee on natural gas. The plaintiffs have challenged the new law on the grounds it violates the Pennsylvania and U.S. Constitutions and endangers public health, natural resources, communities and the environment.
 
In April, the Court issued a preliminary injunction against a portion of Act 13 ensuring that local zoning ordinances dealing with oil and gas operations remain in effect and were not immediately pre-empted by Act 13 on April 14, 2012.  On July 26, the Commonwealth Court declared the state-wide zoning provisions in Act 13 unconstitutional, null, void and unenforceable. The Court also struck down the provision of the law that required DEP to grant waivers to the setback requirements in Pennsylvania’s Oil and Gas Act.
 
The municipalities are: Township of Robinson, Washington County; Township of Nockamixon, Bucks County; Township of South Fayette, Allegheny County; Peters Township, Washington County; Township of Cecil, Washington County; Mount Pleasant Township, Washington County; and the Borough of Yardley Bucks County.  Attorneys for the Petitioners are Jordan B. Yeager, Susan Kraham of Columbia University School of Law Environmental Law Clinic, John M. Smith, Jonathan M. Kamin, William A. Johnson, Esq.  At least seventy local governing bodies from throughout Pennsylvania have either adopted a resolution or voted to send a letter in support of the lawsuit based on the unconstitutionality of the law.
 
For information on how local governing bodies can express support for the challenge to Act 13 click here.

Visit EcoWatch’s ENERGY and FRACKING pages for more related news on this topic.

 

EcoWatch Daily Newsletter

Pexels

By Daniel Yetman

Bleach and vinegar are common household cleaners used to disinfect surfaces, cut through grime, and get rid of stains. Even though many people have both these cleaners in their homes, mixing them together is potentially dangerous and should be avoided.

Read More Show Less
During a protest action on May 30 in North Rhine-Westphalia, Datteln in front of the site of the Datteln 4 coal-fired power plant, Greenpeace activists projected the lettering: "Climate crisis - Made in Germany" onto the cooling tower. Guido Kirchner / picture alliance / Getty Images

Around 500 climate activists on Saturday gathered outside the new Datteln 4 coal power plant in Germany's Ruhr region, to protest against its opening.

Read More Show Less
Dr. Mark Brunswick (2R), Vice President of Regulatory Affairs and Quality, walks through the lab at Sorrento Therapeutics in San Diego, California on May 22. ARIANA DREHSLER / AFP / Getty Images

By Julia Ries

Around the world, there have been several cases of people recovering from COVID-19 only to later test positive again and appear to have another infection.

Read More Show Less

By Samantha Hepburn

In the expansion of its iron ore mine in Western Pilbara, Rio Tinto blasted the Juukan Gorge 1 and 2 — Aboriginal rock shelters dating back 46,000 years. These sites had deep historical and cultural significance.

Read More Show Less
Meadow Lake wind farm in Indiana. Anthony / CC BY-ND 2.0

By Tara Lohan

The first official tallies are in: Coronavirus-related shutdowns helped slash daily global emissions of carbon dioxide by 14 percent in April. But the drop won't last, and experts estimate that annual emissions of the greenhouse gas are likely to fall only about 7 percent this year.

Read More Show Less
Andrey Nikitin / iStock / Getty Images Plus

By Adrienne Santos-Longhurst

Plants are awesome. They brighten up your space and give you a living thing you can talk to when there are no humans in sight.

Turns out, having enough of the right plants can also add moisture (aka humidify) indoor air, which can have a ton of health benefits.

Read More Show Less

Trending

A bald eagle chick inside a nest in Rutland, Massachusetts. Massachusetts Division of Fisheries and Wildlife
A bald eagle nest with eggs has been discovered in Cape Cod for the first time in 115 years, according to the Massachusetts Division of Fisheries and Wildlife (Mass Wildlife), as Newsweek reported.
Read More Show Less