Quantcast
Environmental News for a Healthier Planet and Life

A Great Lakes Moment

A Great Lakes Moment

Ohio Environmental Council

By Kristy Meyers

Hundreds of people descended on Capitol Hill this February to meet with Congressional members. The agenda—restore and protect our Great Lakes. Government, business and non-profit leaders joined together to share success stories from the Great Lakes Restoration Initiative (GLRI), including projects to reduce nutrient runoff and clean-up polluted harbors. 

During this year’s visit, a small group of people were invited to the White House for a meeting with various federal officials. At this meeting, we learned that the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (ACE) will be speeding up its study of how to separate the Great Lakes and Mississippi River basins to protect the lakes from the destructive Asian carp.

Another topic discussed at the White House was the nutrient pollution overtaking Lake Erie. As a result of the meeting, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and the U.S. Department of Agriculture Natural Resources Conservation Service convened a conference call with a small group of environmental-conservation groups on how to fix the nutrient problem plaguing Lake Erie. We made eight specific requests. (See www.theoec.org/Water.htm).

The pledges and efforts were impressive. But the devil is always in the details. Can the U.S. ACE’s study be completed in 18 months or less? Will the Obama team actually move forward on some of our requests? Will Congress act? We must hold our officials’ feet to the fire and ensure that these efforts not only are carried out, but actually produce meaningful results. 

On the state level, State Rep. Lynn Wachtmann (R-Napoleon) pulled the rug out from under Gov. Kasich with the unexpected introduction of House Bill 473, a revised bill to implement the Great Lakes Compact. Wachtmann had sponsored a flawed Compact bill that Kasich vetoed last July.

The Kasich administration had been working with the House to craft a new bill since the Governor vetoed an overly industry-friendly bill approved mostly along party-lines by the General Assembly last summer. The vetoed bill was opposed by former Ohio Governors Bob Taft and George Voinovich, the Governors of Michigan and New York, and environmental-conservation groups.

While the new bill is much improved, Governor Kasich’s staff has signaled publicly that the bill’s introduction was unexpected and that several important issues remain unresolved.

Conservation groups credit Kasich and the Ohio Department of Natural Resources for achieving substantial improvements in the new bill, including, significantly reduced limits on the amount of water an industrial operation may withdraw or use before triggering a permit, strengthening protections for high-quality streams and grounding in science the management of Ohio’s Lake Erie basin water.

However, the bill would repeal the current Ohio law that requires that both Lake Erie and its tributaries be protected from large water uses. Instead, it extends protections only if the entire Lake Erie basin is threatened by a proposed water withdrawal, leaving individual tributaries and groundwater vulnerable to harm. This flies in the face of the Compact and current Ohio law, which require that tributaries be protected from any water withdrawal or use that may cause significant harm.

In an unprecedented move, HB 473 would restrict anglers, boaters and other Lake Erie recreational water users to appeal a water withdrawal or water use decision that may negatively impact their ability to enjoy Ohio’s rivers and streams. It would allow only water users that can prove injury to a direct economic or property interest to appeal a permit decision. This is an outright abandonment of Ohio’s public trust responsibility and a radical move toward privatizing Ohio’s water and natural resources. 

HB 473 measures water withdrawals and consumptive uses based on an average over a 90-day period as opposed to a “per day” measure. This opens the door for extractive activities, including oil and gas fracking operations, to withdraw and/or consume quantities of water in excess of permit thresholds without having to obtain a permit.  For example, a facility could withdraw 6 million gallons of water in a single day and not consume any more water over the remainder of the 90-day period and not trigger the bill’s proposed gallons-per day threshold for needing to seek a permit.

As the legislation currently is written, water users seeking an experimental permit do not have to meet all the provisions of the decision-making standard within the Compact, particularly the “no significant impact” provision. This provision is required, however, if a permittee wanted to pursue using the technology under the new or increased water withdrawal and consumptive use regulatory program. In addition, the legislation does not outline how many times a water user could apply for this type of permit.

This new legislation allows water users to start building their capacity to withdraw or consume water before being granted a permit, if they are not seeking to pull from a high-quality stream, a first time occurrence in environmental policies. While an applicant would not be allowed to withdraw or consume water without a permit from state regulators, the bill gives industry an economic windfall argument when balancing economic and societal needs against environmental protections.

Lake Erie is a precious resource that is vital to people, wildlife and jobs. Lake Erie supplies drinking water to 11 million people. Tourism and travel in the Lake Erie basin generates $10 billion annually to the Ohio economy and supplies $1.4 billion in federal, state and local taxes.

TAKE ACTION: Contact your state representative and senator today at 800-282-0253 or www.legislature.state.oh.us. and ask them to not roll back protections for tributaries, allow recreational users to appeal a water withdrawal permit, close all loopholes and require water thresholds for a permit be based on a per day basis.

For more information, contact Kristy Meyers at 614-487-5842 or Kristy@theOEC.org.

Former U.S. Sec. of Energy Ernest Moniz listens during the National Clean Energy Summit 9.0 on October 13, 2017 in Las Vegas, Nevada. Isaac Brekken / Getty Images for National Clean Energy Summit

By Jake Johnson

Amid reports that oil industry-friendly former Energy Secretary Ernest Moniz remains under consideration to return to his old post in the incoming Biden administration, a diverse coalition of environmental groups is mobilizing for an "all-out push" to keep Moniz away from the White House and demand a cabinet willing to boldly confront the corporations responsible for the climate emergency.

Read More Show Less

EcoWatch Daily Newsletter

Climate change can evoke intense feelings, but a conversational approach can help. Reed Kaestner / Getty Images

Anger, anxiety, overwhelm … climate change can evoke intense feelings.

"It's easy to feel dwarfed in the context of such a global systemic issue," says psychologist Renée Lertzman.

She says that when people experience these feelings, they often shut down and push information away. So to encourage climate action, she advises not bombarding people with frightening facts.

"When we lead with information, we are actually unwittingly walking right into a situation that is set up to undermine our efforts," she says.

She says if you want to engage people on the topic, take a compassionate approach. Ask people what they know and want to learn. Then have a conversation.

This conversational approach may seem at odds with the urgency of the issue, but Lertzman says it can get results faster.

"When we take a compassion-based approach, we are actively disarming defenses so that people are actually more willing and able to respond and engage quicker," she says. "And we don't have time right now to mess around, and so I do actually come to this topic with a sense of urgency… We do not have time to not take this approach."

Reporting credit: ChavoBart Digital Media
Reposted with permission from Yale Climate Connections.

Trending

A rare North Atlantic right whale is seen off Cape Cod Bay on April 14, 2019 near Provincetown, Massachusetts. Don Emmert / AFP / Getty Images

An extremely rare North Atlantic right whale calf was found dead off the North Carolina coast on Friday.

Read More Show Less
Sprinklers irrigate a field of onions near a Castilian village in Spain. According to a new study, the average farm size in the EU has almost doubled since the 1960s. miguelangelortega / Moment / Getty Images

By Andrea Germanos

A new report released Tuesday details the "shocking" state of global land equality, saying the problem is worse than thought, rising, and "cannot be ignored."

Read More Show Less
Members of the San Carlos Apache Nation protest to protect parts of Oak Flat from a copper mining company on July 22, 2015 in Washington, DC. Brendan Smialowski / AFP / Getty Images

In yet another attack on the environment before leaving office, the Trump administration is seeking to transfer ownership of San Carlos Apache holy ground in Oak Flat, Arizona, to a copper mining company.

Read More Show Less